Did Ming history distort history? Was Ming Dynasty history a Qing Dynasty fiction?

The history books we read, whether they are official or wild, are second-hand information. If you think about the history, the historian wrote it, the emperor will definitely read it, no matter how clear the emperor is, no matter how fair the historian is, it is impossible to disclose it all meticulously. What history books state is not necessarily the real facts, to paraphrase the phrase "history has no truth", you are not the person concerned, and you can never know it with certainty.

As for whether there is a distortion of history, the wording is even more serious, and the benevolent will see the benevolent, and the wise will see the wise, and the viewer can only interpret it according to his personal experience.

Later generations will compile history books for the previous dynasties, especially those who steal the country, and naturally distort the historical facts to a certain extent. But I think it's basically in line with the actual situation. In addition, I remember that people are illustrating that the style and writing style of history are well written, and there are many materials for studying the history of the Ming Dynasty, not only the history of the Ming Dynasty.

Ming Shilu" and "Ming Historical Records" can be used for reference. There is also "Ming Tongjian". If you want to buy a good history book of the Ming Dynasty, it is recommended that you spend those things in the Ming Dynasty.

The history of the Ming Dynasty was compiled by the Qing Dynasty, and the Qing Dynasty people naturally wanted to discredit in order to consolidate people's thoughts, which was a political means and human nature, after all, the Ming Dynasty was its mortal enemy, such as Shenzong, Wuzong, and Shizong, although they were not Ming monarchs, but they were all smeared to a certain extent.

Let me tell you: as long as it is historical data, it is impossible that there are no distortions, but there are just some differences! The aim may be to force face, political means, and so on.

There are too many doubts in the "History of the Ming Dynasty" that are cultivated by the Manchurians, and there is no reference value, and under what environment was the wild history born? It's all a mystery.

The history of the Ming Dynasty is not a fiction of the Qing Dynasty. The Ming Dynasty was a dynasty in Chinese history, and Zhu Yuanzhang, the Taizu of the Ming Dynasty.

Established. In the early days, the capital should be Tianfu, and the capital was moved to Shuntianfu during the Ming Dynasty. Sixteen emperors, a total of 276 years.

The territory of the Ming Dynasty encompassed the Han Dynasty, reaching the Sea of Japan in the northeast, the Outer Xing'an Mountains, and then shrinking to the Liao River Valley; reach Yin Mountain in the north, and then retreat to the Great Wall of the Ming Dynasty; West to Hami, Xinjiang, and then retreat to Jiayuguan.

Southwest to Burma and Siam.

in the north, and then turned back to about present-day Yunnan; And in the Qinghai-Tibet area, there was a detention guard, and also recovered Annam.

A brief introduction to other situations in the Ming Dynasty.

In the Ming Dynasty, the handicraft industry and commodity economy flourished, a large amount of commercial capital was transformed into industrial capital, and commercial market towns and capitalism sprouted. Culture and art are becoming secularized. According to the "Ming Shilu".

The peak population is 71.85 million, some scholars point to more than 100 million, and there are also claims that the population of the late Ming Dynasty is nearly 200 million.

I think it still has a certain value, it can help people now, understand the social customs of the time, and can also be used to assist in excavating some cultural relics.

I think it's important to look at this in two ways, because history is really a notebook of the victors.

The history of the Ming Dynasty is indeed very strange, and it cannot be ruled out that it is the ugliness of history.

The history books show that the dynasty is always full of disasters and difficulties, and the plague epidemic is caused by disasters from heaven, thousands of miles from north to south, north to Saiwai, south to the Yellow River, and the plague is rampant, resulting in ten rooms and nine emptiness. Take the capital at that time, for example, 40% of the people died at once; Blessings are incomparable, and there was a serious outbreak of pneumonic plague in Tianjin at that time. According to the history books, "Since August, it should have been September 15.

On the second day, there were no less than hundreds of people on the day of the deceased, and there were even those whose entire families died without leaving a single person, and none of them were saved. ”

Later generations found that the strangeness of the history of the Ming Dynasty was that the Qing Dynasty scandalized the history of the Ming Dynasty, after all, this history had been re-recorded! It is rumored that before the fall of the Ming Dynasty, there was a vision in the sky. It is also said that when Emperor Chongzhen ascended the throne, the sky was clear one second, and the lightning and thunder were thundering in the next second, so many people thought that this was a sign of the death of the country, but many people preferred to believe that there was a vision in the sky that everyone fabricated.

The reason for the fall of the Ming Dynasty

The Ming Dynasty was a dynasty in history when eunuchs were in turmoil, and there were various peasant uprisings, etc., and there were many natural disasters in the Ming Dynasty at that time, so it can be said that the people were miserable, and the people were not able to make a living. The main reason why the Ming Dynasty fell has a lot to do with the political bench and the rule of the political bench, the eunuchs are in power, the government is corrupt, the imperial court is rising, the internal instability is also unstable, the imperial power is not centralized, and the military power is gradually weak.

All kinds of plagues, droughts, insect plagues, etc., the number of displaced people is increasing, and many people are homeless. The displaced people also developed negative feelings towards the country, and gradually there were peasant uprisings and other incidents. It can be said that internal and external troubles, the treasury of the Ming Dynasty is slowly running short, and the army is almost unable to support it, these factors accumulate and accelerate the demise of the Ming Dynasty.

It depends on which aspect it refers to.

As a unified dynasty that lasted for nearly 300 years, the Ming Dynasty had peaks and valleys. There are many aspects that are really unbearable, such as the appearance of the most famous eunuchs, the most severe secret services, the emperor who is a hostage, the emperor who is a carpenter, the emperor who does not go to court for forty years, the emperor who is addicted to drugs, and so on. And obviously there is still a chance, but he still ruined himself.

But there are still many commendable places, sweeping away the Japanese invaders, seven trips to the West, Yongle Grand Ceremony, sweeping Mobei ......

There is nothing like that, "I have been in the Ming Dynasty for 276 years, no harmony, no compensation, no land, no tribute, the Son of Heaven guards the country, and the king dies." "It's so awesome (for example, there is no land cut, but the land north of the Great Wall is basically given up by itself, and it is no different from land cut), but it is not particularly unbearable, otherwise how can it last for nearly three hundred years.

The Ming Dynasty was the last dynasty established by the Han Chinese, how could it be unsightly?

In the early days, needless to say, Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Di's military strength must have been the strongest.

Even in the last years of Chongzhen, if Emperor Chongzhen was not too anxious, he would not have lost the country.

As the saying goes, born in sorrow and die in peace, the Ming Dynasty also had strong times.

It's just that because he was born in peace, the court was corrupt, the internal structure was bloated and unreasonable, the efficiency was poor, and the greed for life and fear of death as an official was caused.

The defeat of a dynasty has a lot to do with its corruption, incompetence, greed and pleasure.

No matter what history says about the dynasty, it is doomed to failure, and history is often written for the victors.

Not really.

Just to name the following people:

Lanling Xiaoxiaosheng, Feng Menglong, Tang Xianzu.

Wang Wensu, Xu Guangqi.

Wang Yangming, Li Zhen, Huang Zongxi.

Every dynasty is a process from prosperity to decline, and the general trend of the world must be divided for a long time, and it must be divided for a long time! Just look at Jiajing, Wanli, and waiting for the Yellow Emperor is quite unbearable!

The Ming Dynasty was the most backbone dynasty in Chinese history, no harmony, no indemnity, no land cession, no tribute, the Son of Heaven guarded the country, and the king died in Sheji.