Why is Xu Shu in Cao Ying, and his heart is in Han

He thought that Cao Cao had killed his mother, and vowed not to come up with a plan for Cao Cao. reflects that Cao Cao does not know how to buy people's hearts.

"Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word"., the allusion is from the literary work "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". Xu Shu became Liu Bei's military advisor by self-recommendation, but was deceived by Cao Cao's advisor Cheng Yu into Cao Ying. Later, Cao Cao's troops attacked Fancheng where Liu Bei was stationed in eight ways, and at Liu Ye's suggestion, Cao Cao sent Xu Shu to Fancheng to persuade Liu Bei to surrender, but after Xu Shu arrived in Fancheng, he told Liu Bei that the army was coming, and asked Liu Bei to prepare early.

Liu Bei wanted to keep Xu Shu, but Xu Shu was afraid that the world would laugh at him, so he refused on the grounds that Liu Bei was assisted by Zhuge Liang, and told Liu Bei that although he was in Cao Cao's camp, he swore not to offer a plan for Cao Cao. After "Xu Shu entered Cao Ying" and "Guan Yu descended to Cao", the incident evolved into the idiom "the body is in Cao Ying, and the heart is in Han".

**In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Xu Shu turned himself into a list of blessings and originally wanted to go to Jingzhou Liu Biao, but after seeing Liu Biao, he felt that Liu Biao was indistinguishable from good and evil, so he left a letter to say goodbye to him, and went to Sima Hui to confide in him, and Sima Hui said that he had Wang Zuozhicai. After Liu Bei returned to Xinye on the horse Tanxi, Xu Shu, under the guidance of Sima Hui, played a long song on Liu Bei's way back to the city in the market, expressing his desire to choose the master.

After Liu Bei heard the singing, he went to meet Xu Shu and worshiped Xu Shu as a military advisor. Cao Cao learned that Liu Bei was stationed in Xinye, and sent Cao Ren to lead a large army to attack, and Xu Shu used a strategy to send Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun to break Cao Ren's forward, and killed Lü Kuang and Lü Xiang. Later, Cao Ren personally ordered troops to come, and Li Dian was defeated by Zhao Yun again, so Cao Ren set up eight golden lock formations, but Xu Shu quickly saw through the flaws in the formation and sent Zhao Yun to lead five hundred soldiers to break the formation and defeat Cao Ren.

There must be filial piety, if there is no filial piety, then it will definitely not go to Cao Cao, secondly, you must have a fearless spirit that is not afraid of death, after all, in Cao Ying, but there is no plan, this is also more death-oriented, he did it, naturally he is not afraid of death.

This is because Xu Shu planted the seeds of hatred in his heart, and he is also a very capable person, but there was no way to change his situation at that time, so he could only endure it all the time.

Because Liu Bei was very good to him, and he also respected Liu Bei very much, but because of family reasons, he had to work under Cao Cao.

Xu Shu was in Cao Ying, his heart was in Han, but the reason why Cao Cao didn't kill him was that Cao Cao used Xu Shu's filial piety to trick him into Cao Ying, and killing a filial person would let him be scolded and affect Cao Cao's reputation. The second is that there are many strategists under Cao Cao's account, whether there is Xu Shu or not, as long as Xu Shu is not used by his opponent Liu Bei. <>

During the Three Kingdoms period, Liu Bei and Cao Cao can be said to be quite opposed, one is Liu Huangshu, a descendant of the royal family, and the other is Cao Cao, who ordered the princes to be the son of narrow heaven. Liu Bei, who supported the Han Dynasty, was naturally inseparable from Cao Cao, who seized the power of the Han Dynasty, and Liu Bei, who was just starting out, finally got the strategist Xu Shu, and was deceived by Cao Cao's design when he got better. Liu Bei was also helpless, but Cao Cao was proud.

I never thought that after Cao Cao deceived Xu Shu, Xu Shu did not offer a plan. Cao Cao has already used deception to deal with Xu Shu, if he kills him again because Xu Shu does not offer a plan, it will seem that Cao Cao is too ruthless, and it will affect the reputation of recruiting talents in the future, and Cao Cao will naturally not kill Xu Shu. <>

Although Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes, the etiquette and righteousness of putting good and filial piety first penetrated into the hearts of the people of the world early, and Cao Cao also knew this clearly. If you want to have a good reputation and think about future generations, you will not do anything to kill the filial people. Xu Shu is a famous person of filial piety, Cao Cao deceived Xu Shu in the name of Xu Shu's mother through a scheme, Xu's mother died for righteousness, leaving Xu Shu is already a very sad thing, Cao Cao can no longer bear to kill the filial Xu Shu.

Cao Cao is also a person who cherishes talents, and he attaches more importance to his advisers, even people like Jiang Gan did not kill Jiang Gan because he was designed by Zhou Yu. Cao Cao is still relatively rational in dealing with strategists, and the same is true for Xu Shu. Xu Shu confronted Cao Cao many times at Liu Bei's place, and Cao Cao tricked Xu Shu into coming not to kill him, but he didn't want to go to Xu Shu for Liu Bei's use.

There are many strategists under Cao Cao's account, and it will not be affected by a Xu Shu who is in Cao Ying's heart in Han. Xu Shu doesn't offer advice, and he also doesn't help Liu Bei, so it's okay, Cao Cao has always kept Xu Shu and can still have a reputation for treating people generously and cherishing talents. Only when others saw that Cao Cao could be lenient to a person whose heart was in the opponent, wouldn't it be better for the strategists who were bent on assisting Cao Cao.

Cao Cao's practice of not killing Xu Shu is more beneficial than disadvantageous in any way, so he will not kill Xu Shu.

The main reason is that Cao Cao wants to use him to attract the heroes and heroes of the world, so that the heroes and heroes will be obedient, and he wants to reuse him, so as to give advice for himself.

Because Cao Cao cherishes talents more and respects Xu Shu more, he has never killed him.

Cao Cao felt guilty about him, arrested his mother, and forced his mother to death in disguise.

"Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word".

When Liu Bei was filial piety in Xinye, Xu Shu turned the list into a blessing, served Liu Bei, and was worshiped as a military advisor. "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" wrote that when he didn't go to Cao Ying, he had asked Liu Bei to invite Zhuge Liang, and he had already invited him. When Cao Cao went south to attack Liu Bei, Liu Bei abandoned Xinye, ran to Fancheng, went to Dangyang, and closed Xiakou, Shu Yu was separated from his mother, and his mother was obtained by Cao, forcing Shu to surrender, Shu was helpless, for his mother, ran Cao Cao, when Yang Changbanpo, Zhao Yun killed a seven in and seven out, why did he not hang, the reason is that Xu Shu made a lot of force, when Cao Cao saw Zhao Yun so powerful, he wanted to capture Zhao Yun alive, but he didn't catch it for a long time, and the strategist said to shoot with a bow and arrow, Xu Shu said:

If the prime minister can capture this person alive, he will definitely be able to persuade him to be used by the prime minister, Cao Cao gave an order at that time: as long as Zhao Yun is alive, don't die Zilong. Therefore, Zhao Yun and Adou can rush out of Changban Slope, if it weren't for Xu Shu, 10 Zhao Yun would not be able to do without Changban Slope.

This was the first strategy he gave Cao Cao.

Second: When the Red Cliff was fighting, Pang Tong offered a serial plan, and after he came out, he was grabbed by Xu Shu and said: Huang Gai used a bitter meat plan, xx deceitful book, you have a serial plan, are you afraid that Cao Ying will not burn the wheelsman?

Pang Tong pulled Xu Shu aside and said, do you really want to tell me about it? The file said: If I tell you that I will not come to you.

Anyway, Cao Ying is going to burn, you teach me a way to get out? Pang Tong told Xu Shu that you were spreading rumors in the army, saying that Xiliang Ma Teng, and Han Sui was going to send troops to take Chang'an. So he took the initiative to ask for orders to go to Sanguan to defend Ma Teng and Han Sui, and escaped the fire of Chibi.

It seems that he gave Cao Cao these two strategies for the rest of his life, and he was not written in the later deduction.

According to historical records, Xu Shu was indeed "in Cao Ying's heart in Han", once Cao Cao asked Xu Shu to persuade Liu Bei to surrender, but after this Xu Shu saw Liu Bei, he actually told Liu Bei that the army was coming, so that Liu Bei could take precautions, and Xu Shu's official position in Cao Ying was not high, so it can be seen that Xu Shu did not give Cao Cao advice, otherwise according to Xu Shu's talent and ability, he would have already reached the same status as Xun Yu, Xun Yu and others.

First of all, although "being in Cao Ying's heart in Han" is a beautified story, there is no record of Xu Shu giving advice to Cao Cao in history, at that time Xu Shu just wanted to help Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang was recommended by Xu Shu to Liu Bei, as a result, Cao Cao's strategist Cheng Yu thought that Xu Shu was a usable talent, so he used Xu Shu's mother to threaten Xu Shu, so that Xu Shu left Liu Bei and came to Cao Ying, but Xu Shu did not give Cao Cao advice, but kept silent, and even when Cao Cao asked Xu Shu to persuade Liu Bei, Xu Shu sent a message to Liu Bei.

Secondly, during Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, he had heard about Xu Shu's situation in Cao Ying, and Zhuge Liang was still sighing at that time: "Are there so many talented people in Cao Wei?" Why can't even Xu Shu be reused?

It can be seen from Zhuge Liang's sentence that Zhuge Liang thinks that according to Xu Shu's ability, he can achieve a very high official position, but obviously Xu Shu at that time was not reused, if Xu Shu really tried his best, then it is impossible to have a mediocre official position, from this one thing it is enough to see that Xu Shu should not give Cao Cao or Cao Pi advice, but just do his own job and serve the people, so that Xu Shu's official position and status are very low.

Finally, as for whether Xu Shu really has Liu Bei's heart, in fact, everyone has no way of knowing, after all, Xu Shu has been in Cao Ying for a long time, and he never thought about returning to Shu Han later, which also shows that Xu Shu may not have thought about him anymore, and only wants to "live in troubled times".

Xu Shu was a famous strategist during the Three Kingdoms periodXu Shu was one of the famous strategists in the Three Kingdoms period, with a high reputation in Jingzhou, and because Xu Shu was very talented, many princes actually wanted to ask Xu Shu to go out of the mountain to assist, but Xu Shu never came out of the mountain, because Xu Shu was also waiting for Ming Jun; And this is the time for Liu Bei to appear in front of him, although Liu Bei's group was weak at that time, repeatedly defeated and had taken refuge in many princes, Liu Bei came to Jingzhou because he defected to Jingzhou Liu Biao; But after Xu Shu talked with Liu Bei, he found that Liu Bei was very benevolent and righteous, and he was still a member of the Han family, so Xu Shu thought that Liu Bei was the Ming Jun he was waiting for, so he went out of the mountain to assist Liu Bei. <>

Xu Shu is very wise and capableNot long after Xu Shu went out of the mountain to assist Liu Bei, Liu Bei's group was attacked by Cao Wei's group, and the leader was Cao Ren, the famous general of Cao Wei Group, and also placed the Eight Golden Lock Array to pose a great threat to Liu Bei's Group, but the Eight Golden Lock Array could not test Xu Shu, so Xu Shu told Zhao Yun about the method of breaking the formation, and Zhao Yun cracked Cao Ren's Eight Golden Lock Array and defeated Cao Wei's army; Later, Cao Ren's army guarded Fancheng, but Xu Shu used a strategy to attract Cao Ren out of the city, and ordered Guan Yu to attack Fancheng and also captured Fancheng in one fell swoop.

Xu Shu is in Cao Ying, and his heart is in HanCao Ren's defeat attracted Cao Cao's attention, so he learned that Liu Bei's group was able to defeat Cao Ren because of the strategist Xu Shu's plan for Liu Bei, so Cao Cao asked Xun Yu about Xu Shu's talent, and Xun Yu did not hesitate to praise Xu Shu and said: His talent is several times better than mine. So Cao Cao Aicai eagerly grabbed Xu Shu's mother to blackmail Xu Shu to join the Cao Wei Group, and Xu Shu finally chose to leave Liu Bei for the safety of his mother, and recommended Zhuge Liang, a famous man in Jingzhou, before leaving; After coming to Cao Wei's group, Xu Shu never offered a plan for Cao Cao, and later Xu Shu asked to be transferred to the border to live in seclusion.

It is indeed in Cao Ying's heart in Han, because Xu Shu did not give Cao Cao a plan, but because his mother was arrested by Cao Cao, Xu Shu had to go, and before going to Cao Ying, he recommended Zhuge Liang to Liu Bei.

I think so. In fact, he really wanted to be with Liu Bei. It's just that he always feels that Liu Bei doesn't trust him. If you are with him, you may be killed.