Which of the eight banners of the Qing Dynasty was the most powerful? Which of the Eight Banners of

Updated on history 2024-08-10
16 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-15

    In the early days of the Eight Banners system, the independence of each flag was strong, there was an obvious difference between strength and weakness, initially the old four flags (yellow, white, blue, red) strong, the new four flags (four bordered flags) weak, Nurhachi died when the stronger was Zhengbai (Huang Taiji), Zhenghong (Daishan), Zhenglan (Mang Gurtai), after Huang Taiji ascended the throne after some adjustments, the strongest flag is Zhenghuang, inlaid yellow (all are Huang Taiji bring, but inlaid yellow is weaker than Zhenghuang), Zhenglan (Huang Taiji's eldest son Haoge), the imperial power in the early years of Shunzhi was weak, The strongest flag is Dolgon, Duoduo brothers led the two white flags and the blue flag, after the death of Dolgon, Shunzhi vigorously strengthened the imperial power, the strongest of the eight banners became the Son of Heaven self-led yellow, inlaid yellow, white three flags, after that, until the Qianlong Dynasty eight banners of the Beijing camp, the garrison system continued to change, the status of the flag owner was weakened, the upper three banners and the lower five banners were actually led by the emperor.

    Whether it is the Xiaocai Battalion, the Jianrui Battalion and the like in the capital or the garrisons in various places, they are all remixed and woven from the Eight Banners to form new combat units, and the Eight Banners have increasingly become a "household registration organization", so it is impossible to talk about who is strong and who is weak, and even if you only look at the status, you can't see it clearly (for example, in the Eight Banners of the Guangzhou Garrison, the status of the upper three banners is much lower than that of the lower five banners, because the former was adapted from the original Shang Kexi feudal soldiers).

    Objectively speaking, the Eight Banners of the Qing Dynasty should not have had a single flag battle, generally each subordinate and each leader drew a number of tasks together, or went out in the form of left and right flanks (the left wing is inlaid with yellow flags, positive white flags, inlaid white flags, and positive blue flags; The right wing is the yellow flag, the red flag, the red flag, and the blue flag), so it is difficult to distinguish which flag has the highest combat effectiveness from a quantitative point of view.

    However, if we look at the battle sequence at the bottom, shoulder, and ends, it seems that the two blue flags are relatively harder because they are in a position to form an encirclement. However, if you analyze it from the perspective of the excellent being the Praetorian Guard, then the Shangsanqi, which is led by the emperor himself, seems to be the best.

    In addition, the Eight Banners Army has a forward battalion, a guard battalion, and a cavalry battalion in actual combat. For example, the three battalions of the Old Summer Palace are often based on battalions rather than flags. Therefore, to sum up, I personally think that it is really difficult to rank the combat effectiveness of the single flag color of the Eight Banners.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-14

    Personally, Mongolia is inlaid with blue flags, generally the emperor of the Qing Dynasty personally is the main banner of the strong combat power, the upper three banners have status, the lower five banners have no status at all, and the palace guards are all the children of the three banners, and the treatment of the lower flag is not as good as the three banners, and it is always unequal in rank.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    The Manchu Qing Dynasty relied on this system to rise, and the eight banners were: the Yellow Flag, the Yellow Flag, the White Flag, the White Flag, the Red Flag, the Red Flag, the Blue Flag, and the Blue Flag.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    The status of the three flags is the highest.

    Eight Flags. It is divided into three flags and five flags. The owner of each flag of the three banners is concurrently served by the emperor; Under the five banners, each banner lord has a lord.

    Yellowed by the Emperor.

    The three flags of yellow and white are called the three flags; The inlay is white under the control of the kings and Baelor.

    The five flags of blue, blue, red and red are called the lower five flags. The upper three banners are worshiped than the lower five banners, which are the emperor's personal soldiers, serving as the guards of the palace and other tasks, and the lower five banners are stationed in Beijing and various places.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    In the Eight Banners system of the Qing Dynasty, the best status was the Zhenghuang Banner. Royalty-exclusive.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Inlaid Yellow Flag (Manchu: also known as "Xiang Huang Flag", the "Head Flag" of the Eight Banners of the Qing Dynasty (Manchu: the head of the Eight Banners. It is named after the yellow flag with a red edge. There are also yellow flags and white flags.

    Influenced by the concept of "positive and deputy" in Han culture, modern people and film and television dramas mistakenly believe that the Zhenghuang Flag is the first of the Eight Banners. In fact, the inlaid yellow flag is the head flag of the eight flags, and the emperor's household registration is also registered in the inlaid yellow flag, which is called "the first staff leader of the inlaid yellow flag, the first assistant leader on the royal name".

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    1. Inlaid with yellow flags, status: the head of the three flags, the owner of the flag: the emperor is in charge.

    2. Zhenghuang flag, status: three flags, flag owner: emperor pro-unity.

    3. Positive white flag, status: three flags (included in the Shunzhi Emperor), flag owner: the emperor is pro-unified.

    4. Inlaid with white flags, status: under the five flags, flag owners: kings, Baylor and Beizi are divided.

    5. Positive Red Flag, Status: Under the Five Banners, Banner Owners: Kings, Baylor and Beizi Division.

    6. Inlaid with red flags, status: under the five flags, flag owners: kings, Baylor and Beizi are divided.

    7. Positive Blue Banner, Status: Lower Five Banners (Lowered by Dolgon), Banner Owners: Kings, Baylor and Beizi.

    8. Inlaid with blue flags, status: under the five flags, flag owners: kings, Baylor and Beizi are divided.

    The surnames of the children of the Eight Banners include: Tong (Tong Jia), Guan (Guarjia), Ma (Ma Jia), Suo (Suo Xue Luo), He (Hesheri), Fu (Fucha), Na (Nala), Lang (Niu Hulu).

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Among the eight flags, the yellow flag, the inlaid yellow flag, and the white flag are directly under the control of the emperor, and belong to the emperor's personal soldiers, and the treatment conditions are generous, called "the three flags". The red flag, the red flag, the white flag, the blue flag, and the blue flag are led by the prince, the county king, the Baylor, and the shell, and are called the "five flags".

    The status of the Eight Banners is in the order of inlaid yellow, positive yellow, positive white, positive red, inlaid white, inlaid red, inlaid blue, and inlaid blue.

    The highest status of the Eight Flags is the Yellow Flag. The nine aristocratic families of the Qing Dynasty, such as the Guarjia clan, the Niu Hulu clan, the Borzigit clan, and the Yehenala clan, all came from the yellow flag.

    In the early days of Nurhachi's reign, the Eight Banners system had only three flags, namely the black flag, the white flag, and the red flag, and later with the continuous growth of the Later Jin, the number of people also increased exponentially, and gradually developed into the Eight Banners. The original red flag is divided into two flags: positive yellow and inlaid yellow; The original white flag is divided into three flags: white, inlaid white, and blue; The original black flag is divided into three flags: red, red and blue, and the status of the eight flags is arranged in the order of yellow, yellow, white, red, white, red, blue, and blue.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    3. The most noble is tantamount to the yellow flag, whether it is from Nurhachi's army, or the successive kings of the Qing Dynasty, the yellow flag is the elite part of their own soldiers. In this one, in addition to focusing on the training of force, they also pay attention to the cultivation of political strategy, so in this branch, there are either literary talents or martial arts. In the flag-carrying ceremonies of the later Qing dynasties, anyone who was valued by the emperor would basically be included in the yellow flag instead of other flags.

    So we can't say which flag is the most powerful, because the criteria for judging are different, but in any case it is a symbol of Manchu culture, and its existence has changed history.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The eight banners of the Manchu Qing Dynasty are the yellow flag with the yellow flag, and the red flag with the red flag. The white flag is inlaid with a white flag, and the positive blue flag is inlaid with a blue flag. The most powerful and powerful belongs to the Zhenghuang Banner, and the general owner of the flag is the emperor himself.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    The eight flags of the Qing Dynasty are yellow, white, red, blue, yellow, white, red, and blue; The most powerful is the Zhenghuang Banner, because it is directly controlled by the emperor.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    They are the positive yellow flag, the positive red flag, the inlaid red flag, the inlaid blue flag, the inlaid yellow flag, the positive white flag, the inlaid white flag, and the positive blue flag, of which the positive yellow flag, the inlaid yellow flag, and the positive white flag are controlled by the emperor. The strongest is the yellow flag, and the strength is the strongest.

  13. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    The eight flags of the Qing Dynasty are the yellow flag, the yellow flag, the white flag, the white flag, the red flag, the red flag, the blue flag, and the blue flag. Among them, the yellow flag is the most powerful, and it is called the head flag!

  14. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Nurhachi's strongest early was the positive yellow flag, and in the later period, the positive yellow flag was divided into three and given to Azig, Dolgon, and Duoduo, who were inlaid with yellow flags on their own collars, and the positive yellow flags in the Huang Taiji period, and the positive white flags of Dolgon in the early Shunzhi period, and the yellow flags in the later period.

  15. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    The upper three flags and the lower five flags.

    The upper three flags are inlaid with yellow flags, yellow flags, and white flags, and at the beginning of the establishment, the yellow flag is the first, and then the inlaid yellow flag is the most noble.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The eight flags of the Qing Dynasty were: the yellow flag, the yellow flag, the red flag, the red flag, the white flag, the white flag, the blue flag, and the blue flag. The Eight Banners originally originated from the hunting organization of the Manchurian (Jurchen) people, and was the form of military organization of the social life of the Qing Dynasty banner people, as well as the fundamental system of the Qing Dynasty.

    In the twenty-ninth year of Wanli in the Ming Dynasty (1601), Nurhachi reorganized the organization, with Niulu Ezhen, Jiala Ezhen, and Gushan Ezhen as the leaders. At the beginning, the yellow, white, red, and blue four color flags were placed and organized into four flags. In the forty-third year of Wanli (1615), four flags were added with yellow, white, red and blue, and the system of eight flags was established.

    The Manchurian (Jurchen) society implemented the Eight Banners system, and Ding Zhuang was a soldier in war and a citizen in peacetime, so that his army had extremely strong combat effectiveness.

Related questions
11 answers2024-08-10

Red, blue, white, yellow, red, blue, white, yellow.

Zheng Huang (45 Niu Lu) and Huang (20 Niu Lu): Nurhachi Zheng White Flag (25 Niu Lu): Huang Taiji Inlaid White Flag (15 Niu Lu): >>>More

2 answers2024-08-10

Early Qing Dynasty: Military Region Commander + Local Administrator. >>>More

3 answers2024-08-10

The Eight Banners originally originated from the hunting organization of the Manchurian (Jurchen) people, and was the form of military organization of the social life of the Qing Dynasty banner people, as well as the fundamental system of the Qing Dynasty. >>>More

14 answers2024-08-10

Strictly speaking, no.

Later, the basic language of the Jurchen nation was gone, and the cultural characteristics also changed, so I don't think it can be said to be a Jurchen, it can be said that it is a descendant of the Jurchen. >>>More