Why is it said that the culprit of the Battle of Jingjing is Zhu Yuanzhang, not Zhu Yunwen?

The shame of Jingkang has undoubtedly become the biggest shame of the Song Dynasty, and the culprit of this disaster is not Zhu Yunwen, but Zhu Yuanzhang, because Zhu Yuanzhang caused great contradictions with the tribes outside when he founded the country, so it led to this disaster today.

The main reason why it is said that the culprit of the "Battle of Jingyan" is Zhu Yuanzhang instead of Zhu Yunwen is that Zhu Yuanzhang knew that the careerist Zhu Di would rebel in the future, and he still insisted on passing the throne to Zhu Yunwen.

Because it was Zhu Yuanzhang who planted the gene of the "Battle of Jingjing": not passing on Zhu Di made him resentful; No** Zhu Di poses a great threat to Zhu Yunwen.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang believed that the princes with different surnames could not be trusted, and only their own descendants could defend the royal family, so they did not divide the feudal surnames and the descendants of the feudal feuds, so the feudal division was formed. It also planted the bane of the Battle of Jingjing.

Yes, the biggest responsibility is not to choose a good inheritance, after all, his fourth son is still relatively strong, and he should think of this.

Yes, this battle is inseparable from Zhu Yuanzhang, because Zhu Yuanzhang passed the throne to his grandson, which led to the emergence of this war epidemic.

We all know that the main reason why Ming Chengzu Zhu Di was able to successfully defeat his nephew Zhu Yunwen was that his father, Ming Taizu Zhu Yuanzhang, killed all the famous generals who followed him to open the country, resulting in Emperor Jianwen being unavailable.

But is this really the case, you must know that Zhu Yuanzhang, as an immediate emperor, would not be unaware of the possibility of the rebellion of the vassal king, so he actually left a few famous generals for Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen, but he didn't use them well. These four celebrities are: Geng Bingwen, Qu Neng, Song Sheng, and Guo Ying.

Let me talk about these four famous players separately.

The first Geng Bingwen.

This Geng Bingwen is the first general left by Zhu Yuanzhang to his grandson, and he followed Zhu Yuanzhang at the age of nineteen. Zhu Yuanzhang killed so many famous founding generals and didn't kill him, because this person was good at fighting and not good at doing good deeds, Zhu Yuanzhang felt that he would not threaten his grandson. After Zhu Di began to settle the rebellion, Emperor Jianwen did send Geng Bingwen, but Geng Bingwen was good at defending and not attacking and was defeated in a head-on battle with Zhu Di, and turned to defense.

Zhu Di had no choice but to attack the city. However, Emperor Jianwen replaced Geng Bingwen at the suggestion of Huang Zicheng and changed it to Li Jinglong, which led to the defeat.

The second place is Qu Neng.

This Qu Neng was the one who fought with Lan Yu, and Lan Yu admired him and recommended him to the emperor. began to follow Geng Bingwen, and Geng Bingwen was defeated and replaced by Li Jinglong. It can be that Li Jinglong is even worse, and he has failed in the war one after another.

Qu Neng led his troops to attack the city in a fit of anger, and just when he was about to capture the city, Li Jinglong wanted to grab the credit and forcibly stopped Qu Neng, but he had no choice but to stop, missing the only chance to defeat Zhu Di.

The third place is Song Sheng.

The famous general's popularity is very low, and the main reason for this is that he has been on the frontier and has fought very bravely. But because there are not many people who know him in the frontier, but Zhu Yuanzhang knows him, as a result, Zhu Yunwen has never used others.

Fourth place: Guo Ying.

This famous general is a contemporary of Geng Bingwen, and he is also Zhu Yuanzhang's most optimistic person, and he also followed Geng Bingwen and Li Jinglong on the expedition. I don't know if Li Jinglong thinks that this veteran is old and has no appearance record at all.

Geng Bing was replaced by Li Jinglong in charge of the army. Qu Neng became Li Jinglong's subordinate, and finally died under Li Jinglong's indiscriminate command. Song Sheng was sent away and deviated from the main battlefield. Guo Ying is under Li Jinglong, and he can only run around with him and has no real power.

None of them went to help. Because they feel that Zhu Di is not worthy of being an emperor, they will want to take this opportunity to take down Zhu Di in one fell swoop.

They all have their own business. Although they are talented, Zhu Yunwen does not reuse them. This also led to his defeat.

The Battle of Jingyan refers to the incident of Zhu Di's seizure of the throne, because Emperor Jianwen cut the feudal domain caused Zhu Di to rebel, and then waved his army south, known as the "Battle of Jingnan" in history.