Li Chengliang and Qi Jiguang are both well known all over the world, why are their life endings so d

Because Qi Jiguang tried to kill all the enemies, and Li Chengliang raised the enemies so that he could attack them in the future, so as to keep his official position.

In fact, I feel that everyone's ending will be different, after all, life is different.

Because they are originally different styles of people, and their attitudes are different, the ending is different.

Of course yes, Qi Jiguang's credit is really very big, he is perfect and lacks the people in the coastal areas, but because he has too much power, he plays Lu and does not listen to the command of the imperial court, so he is not very valued by the imperial court.

Yes, Qi Jiguang's credit is still very large, and he made the coastal border very stable and successfully protected people's safety.

Because Qi Jiguang fought against Japanese pirates, he has been vigorously propagandizing, while Li Chengliang fought against Jurchen Mongolia, and they all became members of the Heavenly Family during the Qing Dynasty, so they are not worth publicity.

No, in fact, both of them have merit, but they are reflected in different aspects, but they are also very accomplished people.

On this issue, I think anyone who knows something about the history of the middle and late Ming Dynasty, especially the Jia, Long, and Wan periods, should be able to tell something. I have read some historical documents of the Ming Dynasty before, and here I would like to answer this question based on historical materials and combine some of my own views.

Li Chengliang was reused in the late Wanli period, mainly due to two factors. First, in the early Wanli period, Li Chengliang had made great achievements in the Liaodong area, and then Li Jiajun also had a good performance in the War of Resistance against Japan and Aid Korea, simply put, Li Chengliang and his son Li Rusong and others themselves had high military talents, which was an important reason for the emperor to reuse Li Chengliang. Second, similar to the situation when Zhang Juzheng recommended Qi Jiguang, there were also high-ranking civil officials in the DPRK and China who supported Li Chengliang at that time.

Because Qi Jiguang is too sharp. That's why Chongzhen will reuse Li Chengliang instead of Qi Jiguang, who is more capable.

Because Emperor Wanli knew that Qi Jiguang's credit was great, he was afraid that he would rebel against him in the future, so he didn't dare to reuse him.

Because Qi Jiguang's success is still supported by Zhang Juzheng, so in the case of Zhang Juzheng and the emperor's contradictions, Emperor Wanli will not continue to reuse Qi Jiguang.

Because Qi Jiguang is Zhang Juzheng's person, and Emperor Wanli doesn't like Zhang Juzheng, and Qi Jiguang is too sharp.

If you just compare the two of them for the Ming Dynasty, I personally think that Qi Jiguang is better than Li Chengliang. In fact, from the perspective of the personal strength of the two, it should be said that they are comparable, but in comparison, Li Chengliang has a fatal stain, which is also a stain on him who is considered a sinner in the Ming Dynasty, so on the whole, it should be the credit of the anti-Japanese hero Qi Jiguang.

When reading the history of the Ming Dynasty, he was moved by Qi Jiguang and his Qi family's army, so he privately thought that he had a better impression of Qi Jiguang, Qi Jiguang's ability was great, which was undoubted, and the Qi family army he led was even more famous all over the world, becoming an army that made the Japanese frightened.

And Li Chengliang, personally, I think that his ability is indeed very great, and later generations have also given great affirmation to his meritorious old man, after all, he has stabilized the situation in Liaodong for more than 30 years, and no one in the Ming Dynasty can take his place after him. But what he is criticized for must be that he cultivated Nurhachi and allowed Nurhachi to grow his power, and when Nurhachi waved his army south, this famous general who had made contributions to the Ming Dynasty became a sinner of the Ming Dynasty.

In fact, it is still a bit one-sided to say that Li Chengliang, or a little unfair, because he also made a choice according to the general environment at that time, the Ming Dynasty's system for the Jurchen tribe at that time was to support the weak and suppress the strong, and whether he let the rise of Nurhachi or not, in fact, he could not stop the development of history, and it seemed inappropriate to really blame an individual for such a crime.

I think it's Qi Jiguang, after all, the Qi family army was very famous back then, and it did a lot of good things, especially in defending the coast against the Japanese invaders, no one has more credit than Qi Jiguang

Qi Jiguang, I think his credit is greater, and his reputation is also relatively great, and he resisted foreign enemies at that time and made great contributions.

Same credit. Li Chengliang's position as a general was not obtained by himself by his real strength, but through his grandfather's hereditary official position, of course, the excellent genes brought by the family generations in the army.

This issue does not need to be discussed, Qi Jiguang is a military strategist. Li Chengliang is a smart man, who basically relies on mercenaries to fight, kill good and take risks, and fool the court. The Korean War also mainly relied on the Qi family army to fully support, and the Liaodong soldiers were behind to grab the merit.

Li Chengliang's military exploits were greater, and he obeyed the governance of Liaodong, while Qi Jiguang's rebellion was powerful, but it was still much weaker than the northern nomads.

I think the latter contributed even more, because Qi Jiguang only resisted the Japanese aggression and protected the safety of the coastal people.

Don't say who has the greatest credit, in terms of my personal national feelings, I prefer the national hero Qi Jiguang, and Li Chengliang, although his military achievements are great, is not as great as Qi Jiguang's contribution to the righteousness of the nation.

I think the credit of both people is great, they belong to different places to guard the frontier against foreign invaders, and from this point everyone has the same credit, both of them are constantly working hard for this country.

Both have meritorious contributions to the heroes, Qi Jiguang has made meritorious contributions to the country in the coastal areas, and Li Chengliang has made meritorious contributions to maintaining border security.

Qi Jiguang knows that he is a famous general who resists the Japanese and has made great contributions to defending the coast, and how famous the Qi family army is, and Li Chengliang has heard of the name, but I don't know the specific deeds.

Qi Jiguang's contribution was even greater, fighting against the Japanese and reaching the Xiongnu in the north. is more meritorious and famous than Li Chengliang.

Because he enjoyed too much fame, fortune and praise in the later period, he slowly became complacent, moved his selfish desires, and betrayed the Ming Dynasty.

Because in the back, his various behaviors hindered the development of Da Ming, and finally watched his desires expand infinitely.

Originally, he was also loyal and ready to serve the country, but officialdom was not so easy to mix, so he hated because of love.

Li Chengliang defeated the Jurchens and captured their leaders Nurhachi and Shulhaqi, and instead of killing them, he took them in as his own slaves. Ten years later, Li Chengliang's wife saw that Nurhachi and Shulhaqi were extraordinary, so she let them go, everyone knows about the follow-up.

BecauseLater, he was greedy for power and his ambitions swelled, slowly began to no longer be loyal to the imperial court, so rebelled against the Ming Dynasty.

Li Chengliang did a lot of good things for the benefit of the country and the people at the beginning, but in the later stage, he was treacherous and his desire increased, which led to a loss of control.

Li Chengliang was greedy for power, and after his ambitions swelled, he forgot his original intention and did a lot of treacherous things.

I think it was because Li Chengliang wanted to make a high merit at that time, add a reward, and make the emperor more annoying, and if he didn't give the official, he wouldn't work for the emperor, so he ended up infamy.