If Zhuge Liang was in command in the Battle of Yiling, could he defeat Lu Xun?

During the Three Kingdoms period, Liu Bei's group occupied Yizhou, and took the opportunity to capture Hanzhong, when Guan Yu, who was guarding Jingzhou, in order to cooperate with Liu Bei, attacked Cao Wei's Xiangfan, at that time, Dongwu was afraid that Liu Bei's group was too strong, and secretly united with Cao Wei, taking the opportunity to sneak attack Jingzhou, Guan Yu was captured and killed, Liu Bei was very sad after getting the news, and made up his mind to take revenge, he led all the soldiers and horses to attack Dongwu, and as a result, Lu Xun burned the company camp for 800 miles during the battle of Yiling, and more than half of the soldiers and horses were lost, and Shu Han went downhill. So if Zhuge Liang is in command in the battle of Yiling, can he defeat Lu Xun? Zhuge Liang has always recognized the alliance with Wu to resist Cao, he will promise the conditions of Eastern Wu to withdraw the army, Zhuge Liang is cautious, will not camp in the woods, so he will not be tricked, Zhuge Liang is in charge, it is difficult for the two sides to fight.

1. Zhuge Liang has always recognized the alliance of Wu to resist Cao, and he will promise the conditions of Eastern Wu to withdraw from the army. Zhuge Liang has been adhering to the strategy of linking Wu to resist Cao since he came out of the mountain, and has always recognized the three-point world, when the Shu Han army attacked Eastern Wu, Sun Quan was very panicked, he proposed to return Jingzhou to Liu Bei, and would hand over the ** who killed Guan Yu, but Liu Bei's brain was hot at the time and did not agree. If Zhuge Liang was in command at that time, he would agree to the conditions of Eastern Wu, and then conclude an alliance with Eastern Wu again, and would not waste soldiers and horses, and then withdraw the army.

Second, Zhuge Liang is cautious and will not set up camp in the woods, so he will not be burned to the camp. Zhuge Liang is very cautious, he will lead the troops to fight will be very meticulous, if he is in command of the battle of Yiling, he will not let the soldiers give up the waterway, nor will he let the soldiers set up camp next to the woods, he has been living in Jingzhou for a long time, and he knows the local geographical location very well, so he will not let Lu Xun burn the company camp, Zhuge Liang can completely defeat Lu Xun. <>

Third, Zhuge Liang is in charge, and it is difficult for him to fight with Dongwu from the perspective of overall interests. Liu Bei had been carried away by Guan Yu's death at that time, he was bent on revenge, although Zhuge Liang had a good relationship with Guan Yu, but he would deal with the problem rationally. He led the troops to fight against Dongwu, and it was difficult to fight with Dongwu, at most he would threaten Dongwu and make Dongwu accept some conditions, and then the two sides would continue to cooperate.

I think it's okay, because Zhuge Liang's intelligence is much stronger than Lu Xun's, he is like a god, he can come up with most of the enemy's plans, and deal with them in time.

I think so. Because Zhuge Liang's strategy is more powerful than Lu Xun's, Zhuge Liang will definitely be able to defeat Lu Xun when he goes on an expedition.

I think it's okay, because Zhuge Liang's combat experience is far above Lu Xun, and if Zhuge Liang is in charge, he can easily defeat Lu Xun.

<> "What would have been the result of the Battle of Yiling if Zhuge Liang had led the army."

From the peak strength of the founding of the State of Shu to its later decline, there was a very critical battle that made it change like this. This battle was the Battle of Yiling, one of the three most famous battles of the Three Kingdoms.

The background of the Battle of Yiling at that time was that Liu Bei avenged Guan Yu, so he took command of Zhongmin and sent troops to Eastern Wu. In the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, it is introduced as follows: "The ancestor attacked Guan Yu with Sun Quan, and then commanded the armies to attack Wu" So, with the comparison of the strength of Shu and Wu at that time, can Shu destroy Wu?

In fact, it is not feasible. Although the description of Wu in the history of the Three Kingdoms is far inferior to that of Wei and Shu, after all, it was developed through the hard work of Sun Jian, Sun Ce, and Sun Quan, and the comprehensive strength is over there. In terms of population, Wu is twice as large as Shu; From the analysis of the army soldiers, the soldiers of Wu are also twice as many as the soldiers of Shu, in ancient times, fighting a war is very important to the number, after all, the era of cold weapons relied on hand-to-hand combat between soldiers; In terms of geographical environment, the territory of Wu is larger than that of Shu.

And it has the Yangtze River, easy to defend and difficult to attack, at this point, the territory of Wu and Shu are very similar, the continuous mountains of Shu have also achieved its characteristics of easy to defend and difficult to attack, since they are both two countries that focus on defense, then it is not easy to attack Wu;

Finally, from a strategic point of view, Longzhong's policy has always been to maintain a good cooperative relationship with Eastern Wu, destroy Wei first, and then take things, so as to win the world.

Analyzing all of the above, it is actually very difficult for Shu to destroy Wu. However, if Zhuge Liang, who fought Wu back then, and Liu Bei who stayed in Chengdu, then the situation would definitely be reversed.

From a historical point of view, in the battle between Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi, Sima Yi was defeated every time, he was very afraid of Zhuge Liang in his heart, and Lu Xun's military talent was far inferior to Sima Yi, so if Zhuge Liang was the leader of the army, Lu Xun would definitely have no way to resist the attack of the Shu army.

And Zhuge Liang has been calm all his life, under his command, it can be said that it is easy to get back Jingzhou, which was stolen by Eastern Wu, but the size of Wu and the distance of Chengdu are easy to have the same problem as the Northern Expedition, that is, the problem of food and salary of the Eastern Expeditionary Army, so it is difficult to destroy Wu, and it is relatively easy to recapture Jingzhou, which sells Yunzhi, and gives Guan Yu a bad breath.

And there is no need to pay the fiasco of the loss of the soldiers in the battle of Yiling. Under Zhuge Liang's management, Jingzhou's strength will definitely be extremely strong, and it will play a very key role in his later Northern Expedition. It's a pity that it was Liu Bei who led the army to the east!

Liu Bei is the founding emperor of Shu Han, he became an emperor from a counterattack who sold straw shoes, you can imagine how many wars he has experienced along the way, and he has been able to turn danger into disaster and establish political power, which shows that he still has two brushes. However, the battle of Yiling made Liu Bei lose particularly badly. This battle is mainly due to the fact that his good brother Guan Yu was killed by Sun Quan of Eastern Wu, and in order to take revenge, Liu Bei personally led a large army to attack Eastern Wu, but was defeated by Lu Xun of Eastern Wu.

So, what are the reasons why Liu Bei fought all his life, but lost to Lu Xun in the Battle of Yiling? First, Liu Bei's tactics were problematic. Second, Liu Bei lightly advanced against the enemy and encountered logistical problems.

Third, Lu Xun's strategy is very appropriate. Fourth, Liu Bei did not have a clear advantage in his forces.

First. Liu Bei did not formulate a detailed strategy according to the specific situation in the battle, did not reconnoiter the geographical advantage, and brought the army into a difficult situation.

Two or three hundred kilometers of rugged mountain roads. Then, in the face of the enemy's insistence, he did not know how to change his operational deployment in time, and adopted the wrong method of setting up camp everywhere without a key point, and finally fell into passivity.

Second. When the battle of Yiling just broke out, the morale of the Shu Han army was full, Liu Bei was even more confident and slow, and after the battle between the two sides, the Shu Han army captured Zigui all the way, and sent the water division down the river to fight, and this made him see the hope of victory, and also made Liu Bei relax his vigilance, since you don't take the enemy in your eyes, then defeat is inevitable. Because of this, Liu Bei rushed forward lightly and penetrated hundreds of miles into the Wu realm.

In the face of the Wu army, which was holding on to important places and not fighting, Liu Bei had no choice but to set up camp, which also led to the dispersion of the Shu army's forces and its inability to deal with the enemy's main force. Moreover, Liu Bei is fighting from a long distance, and there will be problems if the logistics supply is too long. Moreover, it was summer, it was too hot, and there was no choice but to move the naval boat to the land, and set up the military camp in the deep mountains and dense forests.

Third. Lu Xun can be said to be a novice in front of Liu Bei, but his strategy is still very clear. In the face of the menacing Shu army, Lu Xun, as the commander of the Wu army, observed the subjective and objective situation of the two armies, and determined the strategy of luring the enemy into depth, concentrating troops, striking backwards, and breaking the enemy.

It can be said that this is very prepared, he grasped Liu Bei's heart to take revenge and expand the results of the battle, and did not fight with Liu Bei's army, but took the initiative to give up large tracts of land and strategic places, and the large tracts of land he left behind are.

Five or six hundred miles of mountainous areas, which was also very difficult for Liu Bei's army. Then, he waited for the right moment and won by surprise. It can be said that the victory in the Battle of Yiling is inseparable from Lu Xun's strategy.

Fourth. Although Liu Bei went in person, he also brought about 50,000 people. And the strength of Eastern Wu also has 50,000 people, so it can be said that in the face of Liu Bei's active attack, Eastern Wu did not fall behind.

Moreover, Liu Bei lacked capable cadres here, Zhang Fei was still dead before the expedition, Zhao Yun and others did not come, and Zhuge Liang also guarded the rear, so it can be said that Liu Bei was alone. On the contrary, the strength of Soochow is not weak.

Liu Bei did not take the avenue, but took the trail, which happened to be a plan, and in the war, he believed too much in the strength of the Five Tiger Formation, Liu Bei's physical strength was not good in his later years, and this war did not bring Zhuge Liang.

Liu Bei lost to Lu Xun in this war, mainly because Liu Bei's own tactics were problematic, and he did not formulate a detailed plan and strategy during the war. Secondly, because Liu Bei looked down on Lu Xun very much. It was very active in the process of fighting, resulting in no supply of logistical supplies.