Sima Yi is so smart, why did he fall into Zhuge Liang s empty city plan?

Updated on history 2024-03-25
24 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    I personally feel that Sima Yi may not have thought of that, because of the empty city plan, that battle was also a very important battle, Sima Yi was defeated in the first battle, then they would have no way out, so Sima Yi was very cautious about this matter, so Sima Yi fell for Zhuge Liang's empty city plan.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    First of all, I personally feel that Sima Yi did not fall for Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, but he disdained to defeat Zhuge Liang like this, in fact, Sima Yi had already expected that the outcome had been decided, and Shu would be defeated, so he was not in a hurry for a while, he wanted to defeat Zhuge Liang in a more beautiful way, so that the world would know his ability.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    I think Sima Yi is indeed smarter about this problem, but because of his suspicious character, he feels that Zhuge Liang can't be so simple, and Zhuge Liang takes advantage of his character, so it will cause Sima Yi to fall for Zhuge Liang's empty city plan.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because I personally think that no one is perfect, everyone will make mistakes, not to mention a very witty person, Sima Yi is smart, Zhuge Liang is also smart, the two of them depend on who is careless, if one party is careless, it will have immeasurable consequences.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Zhuge Liang is the smartest person in the world I think Sima Yi is so smart, but he will still fall in Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, because it is needed by the plot, and Zhuge Liang's strategy is also very high, Sima Yi thought of Zhuge Liang also thought of it, so Zhuge Liang's cleverness is here.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    I personally feel that Zhuge Liang's wisdom is very powerful in the Three Kingdoms, and this is only needed by the plot, so I think Zhuge Liang's empty city plan may not exist in modern society, and Sima Yi is so smart that it is the plot arrangement, so he will be fooled by Zhuge Liang's ecstasy array.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Si Li Pei Sui Ma Yi just understands too well, so he will pretend to be in the scheme, otherwise once he kills Zhuge Liang, he will no longer be useful in the court of Zhongna Wei State, and his power will be withdrawn.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Because Sima Yi's character was cautious, he was afraid that Zhuge Liang would arrange an ambush, so he chose to retreat.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because he didn't want to come forward himself, he borrowed Zhuge Liang's hand to perform a play.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    I don't think he saw through Zhuge Liang's intentions. If Zhuge Liang was recognized, it was very dangerous at that time. Sima Yi did not have enough resourcefulness to resist Zhuge Liang's empty city plan.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    He really saw through it, because he knew Zhuge Liang very well, and he didn't want to kill Zhuge Liang directly in that war, so he retreated.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Yes, the reason why he didn't go on the offensive was because he thought about himself. If he captures Zhuge Liang, his status and value will be gone, and he will also be damaged by Cao Cao.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    I think Sima Yi was not just bluffed by Zhuge Liang's empty city plan back then, he was deliberately letting Zhuge Liang go. After all, before ordering the siege of the city, you must have some understanding of the situation in the city.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Sima Yi was not intimidated by Zhuge Liang's scheme. But Sima Yi understands very well that once Zhuge Liang is arrested, his use value will be gone, and this will also bring his own life to life, so Sima Yi will not arrest Zhuge Liang.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    There shouldn't be, Sima Yi is so shrewd, even if he has any doubts, he should have sent some people to explore the truth, so it may be because once he successfully defeats Zhuge Liang, he may lose the right to call the army, and he may also be removed because he has lost his value and threatens the emperor.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Although Sima Yi's fame is not as great as Zhuge Liang in history, but his scheming skills and military talents are better than Zhuge Liang. Sima Yi just saw through Zhuge Liang's plan. Sima Yi was not scared away by Zhuge Liang, in fact, he deliberately let Zhuge Liang go.

    He also pretended to say that he could hear the murderous intent in the sound of the piano.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    He saw through it. Because Sima Yi knew that if he killed Zhuge Liang, then his death would not be far away, and he would inevitably kill him as soon as possible, so he didn't go in.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Of course, Sima Yi saw through it, but he also knew that if Shu Han was destroyed now, he would have no use value for Cao Cao, and he would immediately be unloaded and killed by Cao Cao, so he deliberately pretended not to see through it.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Yes, because he is also a very capable person, otherwise he would not be able to compete with Zhuge Liang for so long.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    I have already seen through it, but I didn't break it, and at that time, I still needed the presence of Zhuge Liang to attract Cao Cao's attention.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Sima Yi was so smart, he had already seen through it at that time, but they both understood that they would not live long after killing each other, so they staged this big drama together, so that they could get by in both respects and survive.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Or Zhuge Liang is capable. No matter how Sima Yi can do it. He still didn't dare to enter the city. It shows that Zhuge Liang has figured out Sima Yi's thoughts.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Why didn't Sima Yi enter the empty city and let Zhuge Liang's empty city plan succeed, the real reason was not that Sima Yi was suspicious and did not dare to rush into the army, but because he could not annihilate Zhuge Liang at once, at that time he was jealous and excluded by many people in the Wei Group, and everyone wanted to bomb him **, because his power was too high, as the saying goes, the gun shot the first bird.

    How could Sima Yi establish his majesty in the Wei State and make himself useful so that he would not be attacked by those who were eyeing him in the Wei State all the time? He can only let Zhuge Liang have a certain military strength, so that every time Zhuge Liang conquers him, Sima Yi will be useful, those evil forces in Wei clearly see this, and of course they will not attack Sima Yi, but Sima Yi can't make Zhuge Liang particularly strong, because it will be related to the life and death of Wei.

    Therefore, Sima Yi is in a relatively embarrassing environment, and he must not let Zhuge Liang not have any strength at all, but he must not let Zhuge Liang's military strength be particularly strong, so this is the real reason why Sima Yi forced Zhuge Liang to the empty city, but to everyone's surprise, he did not enter the empty city.

    Sima Yi is a person who grew up slowly in the cracks of history, he can be called a hero, he is much stronger than Zhuge Liang in history, Sima Yi often said: "The soldier who surrenders without a fight, the good is also good." ”

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Sima Yi is a suspicious person who is afraid of failure.

    There is indeed a flaw in the empty city plan: a city, facing a great enemy, there is no tension at all. There was no sound in the city. Sima Yi could also surround the city with a large army.

    Because Sima Yi was preconceived and understood Zhuge Liang's cautious character, he thought that Zhuge Liang would not do this, so under fear, he did not observe carefully and found flaws.

Related questions
19 answers2024-03-25

In fact, Sima Yi was also forced, and he tried his best to assist the little emperor in sorting out the Wei State in the early stage, but then the Cao family couldn't tolerate him, and they were afraid that he would seize power, so they wanted to kill him quickly, so Sima Yi instead of sitting still, it was better to fight hard and replace him.

18 answers2024-03-25

Personally, I think Sima Yi was too cautious to be confused by Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, because the situation at that time was very clear. Zhuge Liang is on the offensive. He went out of Qishan and attacked the Northern Wei Dynasty, but he didn't want to be lost by Ma Tan, so he had to retreat. >>>More

33 answers2024-03-25

Because after Zhuge Liang died of illness, Sima Yi also faced the contradictions between Cao Wei and the Sima family and the internal strife between the Sima family, and had no time to attack Shu.

8 answers2024-03-25

Zhuge Liang should be Sima Yi's lifelong enemy, but in fact they are also real confidants, and they are all excellent. They are also very similar in many ways. Sima Yi has been in a weak position in the years of confrontation, because Sima Yi cannot compete with Zhuge Liang in terms of military ability. >>>More

17 answers2024-03-25

In ancient times, there was a word called chess opponents, two people are quite strong is a very lucky thing, after all, a person standing in a very high position, it is inevitable that there will be some loneliness, this feeling may be the most obvious in the Three Kingdoms era, because there are too many capable people, there are always capable two people fighting together, you can't destroy me, I can't destroy you. For example, Sima Yi and his enemy Zhuge Liang. >>>More