The old man tripped over a dog leash and died, should the 12 year old girl who led the dog be respon

The old man tripped over the dog leash and died, the 12-year-old girl who led the dog should actually be responsible, although she was not yet 18 years old, but after all, there was negligence for the unfortunate death of the old man, even if there is no legal sanction, it is also morally condemned. However, at that time, the girl really didn't know that the old man who fell to the ground and died was broken into the goods because of the rope of the dog she was leading. When she found out afterwards, she was also very scared and blamed herself.

However, everything has already happened, and the girl's reaction after knowing the truth of the matter is also very pitiful, she also feels that she has done something wrong, but she is an unintentional mistake, and the family of the deceased old man finally forgave her. <>

The incident happened near a market in Shunde District, Foshan, Guangdong, the girl led someone else's dog to play, after the dog broke free from the rope, ran wildly, the rope tripped the old man, the old man fell face down, and then was pulled to the hospital by 120 ambulance, even after rescue, unfortunately died. It can be seen that in fact, the girl didn't know that the dog tripped the old man at first. Therefore, when the old man was taken away, she was still in a state of confusion, in fact, it was not indifference, but fear and disbelief.

Then, it can be regarded as influenced by the original family! She is a single-parent family, and her father has been in prison, and after being released from prison, he has been running for a living, and he has never taken care of his daughter. <>

After the accident, the girl was also very scared when she learned the truth of the matter, and she was in fear. Because the girl has been very pitiful since she was a child, between this, the family of the old man felt that they could not make the child worse, and it could be regarded as helping the poor family, so they did not hold the girl responsible. The family of the deceased elderly can be described as very loving and reasonable.

Although they are also immersed in grief, it is not easy to stand in the girl's shoes and think about her. <>

After the incident, netizens praised the family of the deceased old man, and while persuading them to mourn, they also said that the family would definitely have a good reward, after all, they chose to give the girl a road to the future.

I think that the 12-year-old girl who leads the dog should of course be responsible, and should be mainly responsible, because she is 12 years old, she already has the ability to think and act independently, knows what to do and what not to do, and should be responsible for the consequences of her actions.

She should be responsible, but she is a minor, she has no criminal liability, and there is no civil liability, only her parents can bear civil liability.

Should. It was this 12-year-old girl who took the neighbor's dog out, and if he hadn't checked out the dog, there would have been no such thing, so the girl was primarily responsible.

If the girl takes the dog out with the consent of the dog owner, the dog owner should bear 60%-70% of the main responsibility, and the girl's guardian bears 30%-40% of the responsibility; If the girl is pulled out without the consent of the dog owner, the girl's guardian is more responsible and should bear the primary responsibility, and the dog owner bears secondary responsibility.

will not be sentenced, 12-year-old does not need to bear legal responsibility, but it is definitely necessary to compensate, after all, this incident led to the death of the elderly.

I think so, he caused the crime of intentional injury, and the suspect that after the accident, he did not stop the operation in time and provide corresponding help, and caused the complainant to stop the case of life, he will be punished.

Not sure, because this behavior is not intentional, it is an accident, and the specific situation needs to be judged on a case-by-case basis.

I think the responsibility of the girl is greater, after all, the dog owner is more wronged, and his dog is stolen, and he has to bear some responsibility after hurting someone.

I think the responsibility of the girl is greater, after all, such behavior is illegal, and the dog owner is not involved.

Girl. Even if the dog is a neighbor's, but after all, it is because the girl did not pay attention to it, causing the old man to trip, and the girl must be more responsible.

Both parties were responsible, but the dog owner was bigger and didn't take good care of his own dog. And girls also have a responsibility not to walk the dog without the consent of others.

In my opinion, it should be a girl, because it was the girl who did not keep the dog on a leash, and the owner of the dog had kept the dog on a leash in the yard before.

The old man tripped over a dog leash and died, according to relevant investigations, the girl who led the dog was indeed only 12 years old. It's true.

Yes, the girl who led the dog was only 12 years old and was not criminally responsible, so there was no criminal responsibility for this matter.

The old man tripped over a dog leash and fell to his death! The dog was led by a 12-year-old girl, is she responsible?

1. What happened to you? An elderly man in Guangdong Province tripped over a dog leash and died on the spot, which has aroused widespread concern in society. The incident occurred near a market in Shunde District, Foshan City, Guangdong Province, and the dog was led by a little girl, but the dog suddenly broke free and ran forward desperately.

There was an old man standing in front of him, and the dog rushed past him, and the leash tripped the old man, and the old man flew into the air and flipped up, and fell directly to the ground with his face, and after the fall, he was motionless. After the girl with the dog ran over, she didn't pay attention to the old man's situation, but walked away with the dog. In the end, the old man was sent to the hospital for rescue after the arrival of 120, and finally died due to ineffective rescue.

2. Should the girl be responsible for this incident? After the incident, netizens were very angry about this incident, thinking that this girl was very indifferent and uneducated, her dog tripped over others, but she didn't act at all, the old man fell down at that time, and she didn't even look at it. According to the investigation, the girl who led the dog was only 12 years old, she was taking another villager's dog out to play, the dog was usually taken out by its owner when it was always very quiet, every time its owner would lead him, but this time I don't know what the situation was, the dog suddenly ran up, ** preliminary judgment This is an accident.

However, the family of the elderly man did not hold the girl accountable after mediation.

3. Why did the girl behave so indifferently at that time? The girl was only 12 years old at the time, had a younger brother, was a single parent, and they lived with her father. My father had been in prison before, and he had been working part-time since he came out, and he usually had no time to take care of the children, so the two children depended on each other like this.

After the incident, the child's father said that the child had committed petty theft before, but he really didn't have time to take care of the child himself, and he couldn't do anything about her. Therefore, it is conceivable that growing up in such a crippled family, the child's psychology will be affected, and it is inevitable that he will react very coldly to the outside world. In fact, the child did not know that the old man had tripped over a dog leash at that time, and she was also very scared when she knew.

The family of the elderly knew about the situation of the child's family, so they chose to understand, and also hoped that the child would not be affected in the future. I hope that since all parents bring their children into this world, they should educate their children well and create an environment for them to grow up happily.

Don't be responsible. The girl is under 18 years of age and is a minor and is not legally liable, but her guardian is required to bear legal responsibility on her behalf.

A: I don't think the girl is responsible. Since the girl is only 12 years old and legally a minor, the civil liability for this is borne by her guardian (usually the parents), and therefore the responsibility should be borne by the parents, so the girl is not responsible.

The 12-year-old girl with the dog is not responsible, but her guardian is. Because children under the age of 14 are not criminally responsible.

I think the child is also innocent, too young to deal with the problem, and the dog running out is not something she can control, parents should pay more attention.

should be responsible, the child is not yet an adult, and the parents should pay a certain responsibility.

Be responsible, because the girl was indifferent when the dog ran out, and she didn't look at the old man when he fell.

No, because she is a minor and does not have the capacity to take responsibility, which will be passed on to her guardian.

I think a 12-year-old girl needs to be responsible, because the old man's fall was entirely caused by this girl, and she must be held responsible.

None of us want to see such a thing, but for a 12-year-old girl, whose youth is just beginning, we can't be too harsh on her for the sake of humanitarianism, but she still has to bear at least half of the responsibility.

Criminal liability is required. It was the girl who did not control the dog to cause the accident, and she needs to be fully responsible, and the girl escaped after the accident, and the old man died, which is the crime of escape causing death and will be sentenced to criminal responsibility.

The girl is exempt from criminal liability, but her guardian is subject to certain criminal liability, generally detention and financial compensation. There are two main reasons: 1. The girl is not yet 18 years old, and she does not yet have the age to be criminally prosecuted.

This is expressly stipulated in the Criminal Law of China, which is issued by minors. 2. The dog ran around and tripped people, to tell the truth, the dog should be damned, its owner did not say that he ordered the dog to run around, or instructed it to trip the old man, this accident is an accident, and it will be considered in the pursuit of responsibility.

The girl does not need to bear any responsibility, because she is a minor and will only be morally condemned, but her guardian must be responsible for this incident, after all, it was an accident, not intentional, so it is worth understanding.

Of course, it is necessary to bear part of the responsibility, because girls are young and have weak judgment, which is easy to make mistakes, and the elderly also have some responsibility.

She didn't need to bear much responsibility because she was a minor and the responsibility was passed on to her guardian.