Why was the Han and Tang dynasties able to beat the nomads, but the Song and Ming dynasties were alw

Because the Tang Dynasty was a dynasty of all-round development, on the contrary, its economic and military development was very strong, while the Song Dynasty was heavy on literature and light on military force, and its military aspects were relatively too weak.

Because in the Han and Tang dynasties, the nomads were still a small nation, with great power and very little ability, but in the Song and Ming dynasties, the ethnic minorities had developed very strongly.

The Song Dynasty was a turning point, and the Han Chinese and the nomads changed their positions of attack and defense, not only because of the Song Dynasty's corruption, instigation and suppression of military generals, but also because of the evil consequences of the Han people's cultural stagnation. After the pre-Qin princes, China has never produced epoch-making cultural achievements, and it has not learned from other people's nations, and it is destined to lose its advantages one day. The tragedy of the Song Dynasty and the arrival of the Yuan and Qing dynasties in the Central Plains were only a rehearsal of a century of humiliation in modern Chinese history.

This statement is not entirely true. The Song Dynasty really couldn't do it in this regard. However, in the Ming Dynasty, it was still possible, and Zhu Di killed the Mongols to the point that year, and fled four times.

At the beginning of the Song Dynasty, because the Han people were too kind, they should treat the nomads in the same way as others and treat them as others, and they would have died long ago.

Because since the Song Dynasty, the nomads began to have the main military advantage, taking advantage of the special geographical environment, since ancient times, the Han people have mastered most of the advanced production technology, but they have not humbly learned from other ethnic groups to integrate, since the Song Dynasty, the economic and political pattern began to stagnate and go downhill.

It's not that there is no strength, it's that there is no reasonable tactics and determination to fight with the nomads, and they completely want to rely on their numerical superiority to scare the other party, not only the Central Plains troops after the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms, but they have often been captured since the Western Zhou Dynasty, and the Western Zhou Dynasty to the Eastern Zhou Dynasty is not a big defeat, the period before Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty is still a history of humiliation, and it is with the determination to turn the situation around that there was a decisive battle between the Han and the Huns, the Xiongnu were defeated, and the Western Han was also poor. Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty invaded Liao, the Northern Song Dynasty fought Western Xia, and the siege of Baideng in the Ming Dynasty were all failures caused by the light enemy, and the early advantage was obvious, and they were dragged down by their own unreasonable fighting style.

1. Before the Song Dynasty, the Han regime had been on an uphill slope and gradually stagnated since the Song Dynasty.

Second, the Han people have a fatal flaw: they are blind and arrogant, and rarely learn from other ethnic groups.

There are many reasons for this.

At the beginning of the Song Dynasty, it was very bad, the main horse-producing areas were under the control of foreign tribes, and there were no war horses, which was an important reason for the military defeat of the Northern Song Dynasty.

In the initial stage, the Ming Dynasty was still very strong against nomadic forces such as the Northern Yuan. In the last years, the internal peasant army revolted, involving too much force. The Ming Dynasty fell at the hands of the peasant army within. The Qing Dynasty entered the customs unexpectedly, and there were many fluke factors.

In addition, the ethnic nature of the Han nationality was actually very different from that before the Tang and Song dynasties: before the Tang Dynasty, it was almost ancient, and there was a martial atmosphere, and the civil and military officials of the Tang Dynasty could be converted into each other, that is, the so-called generals who went out were prime ministers, who went out were generals, and when they came back, they were prime ministers.

But after the Song Dynasty, the atmosphere was almost the current one, and literature was admired. After the Song Dynasty, a good man in the eyes of people was not to kill the enemy and serve the country, but to be the champion. **, all scholars have won the top prize, and so on.

In the Song Dynasty, because of the chaos of the martial artists in the last years of the Tang Dynasty, the suppression of the martial artists was too powerful, and the whole atmosphere changed.

Because the technology of the Han and Tang dynasties was more developed than that of the nomads, coupled with the relatively strong folk customs and the high morale of the army, they could beat the nomads. The Song Dynasty admired literature and martial arts, and the strength of the army was not as powerful as that of the Han and Tang dynasties, so they were bullied.

Because during the Han and Tang dynasties, the emperor attached great importance to military strength, but the Song and Ming dynasties were always afraid that someone would rebel and did not attach importance to military strength, and was bullied in the end.

Because in the Han and Tang dynasties, the military strength was very strong, so it is said that they could fight the nomads. And in the Song and Ming dynasties, their military strength weakened.

Because during the Tang Dynasty and the Han Dynasty, the strength of the army was very strong. However, by the Song Dynasty, the focus on the economy led to foreign invasions.

This is because the military strength of the Song and Ming dynasties was not strong, and there were no better military talents who could lead the army to success.