-
The old Three Kingdoms is like a storyteller, Peking Opera. New Three Kingdoms like a game.
-
There is no doubt that the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is good-looking! The New Three Kingdoms is garbage!
-
The new version is simply scum, and the lines are traversed at every turn, which is a manifestation of the screenwriter's irresponsibility.
-
Of course, it's the old Three Kingdoms, the old version of the classic, and the more you look at the new Three Kingdoms, the more you can't understand it. The new Three Kingdoms are not as good as the old ones.
-
The old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms has borrowed from the costumes to the picture design, to the character modeling, to the shooting angle. But from the choice of actors, the acting skills and seriousness of the actors are worthy of recognition. The new version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is innovative, and the picture is beautiful.
The important thing is that some viewers in the new version used to watch some confusing questions about the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, such as Guan Zhang Zhao Yun's ability is so great, why did he follow Liu Bei with all his heart? zhu
-
CCTV version, 84 episodes of the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is the best. It's not that the shooting technique is the highest, but the most cultured. "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a talented book, and it must be filmed with cultural charm, from this point of view, the old version of CCTV is the closest to the original.
Watching "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is about culture and charm, not simple stunts, simple actors and simple storylines. "I personally agree with this statement, I have seen the 94 version myself, and I have seen a little bit recently, but I can't stand the comparison. The 94 version of the sight makes people <>
History has a deep understanding. Especially Zhuge Liang played by Tang Guoqiang, who is very expressive, and so is Zhou Yu.
-
From the perspective of a current person, it is still the recent New Three Kingdoms that is more beautiful.
First of all, from the picture, the picture of the recent Three Kingdoms is still relatively good, and the experience of the picture is more in line with the aesthetic standards of modern people, using the shooting technology of the new era, in many pictures are realized where the old technology can not be achieved before, shooting more pictures in line with the history of the Three Kingdoms, no longer as before, there is only a small scene to describe the battlefield in the Three Kingdoms, and now the use of technology is still very good to reflect the hegemony of the various armies in the Three Kingdoms.
And in the visual appearance of the actors, the aesthetic standards of our current people are changing with the changes of an era, and the current people must be more inclined to the current makeup, or the people with modern temperament, which is an inevitable problem, so, for the current people, they must be more inclined to the heart of the Three Kingdoms, that is, in the appearance of the actors, it must be more attractive to the current actors, not only with a beautiful girl like Chen Hao, There are more handsome faces of the new era appearing in this TV series.
In terms of restoration, the current Three Kingdoms still have a better job in the reproduction of the story, at least in the context of the Three Kingdoms, they are very good, in the search for actors, they all fully select actors who meet the temperament of the characters, take Zhuge Liang as an example, found Lu Yi as the actor, fully reflected Zhuge Liang's wisdom, and from beginning to end, he fully gave full play to the changes in the Three Kingdoms, rather than simply favoring a single person.
From these points of view, it is better to have the new Three Kingdoms!
-
Each version has its own classics and shortcomings. Personally, I prefer the new Three Kingdoms. Because many of the character portrayals are relatively in place.
The acting skills of the actors are also nothing to say. Including some martial arts scenes and some stunts, they are far more than the old Three Kingdoms. But there are still some things in it that don't do the feeling of the old Three Kingdoms.
The most memorable thing about the old Three Kingdoms is Zhuge Liang's confident smile holding a fan. There is no doubt that Zhuge Liang played by Tang Guoqiang is unsurpassable. Even if Lu Yi's acting skills are very good, there is no way to surpass such a classic.
He is like the Monkey King of the six-year-old child, who has left a deep imprint on people's psyche. Let the audience think that Sun Wukong is like that, and let the audience think that Zhuge Liang is also like that.
In addition to Zhuge Liang's shortcomings, the other actors of the New Three Kingdoms have nothing to say about their acting skills. What impressed me the most were Cao Cao and Sima Yi. Cao Cao's words and deeds undoubtedly do not show the atmosphere of a successful person. It can be seen that Cao Cao's success was not accidental.
Cao Cao's treachery, cunning, and his courage. was shown by Chen Jianbin . The kind of arrogant laughter that comes after seeing the enemy's flaws. The kind of anger at seeing teammates stupid is all in place.
And if the most classic character in the Old Three Kingdoms is Zhuge Liang. Then the most classic character in the New Three Kingdoms is undoubtedly Zhuge Liang's old opponent, Sima Yi. Sima Yi is sophisticated, cunning, and forbearing.
was perfectly expressed by Ni Dahong. And what I want to see most in my heart is actually the scene of Tang Guoqiang's Zhuge Liang and Ni Dahong's Sima Yi. That's what it's like to be an opponent in chess.
Sima Yi can put up his tail and be a man, and when he has no chance of winning, he can endure humiliation and forbearance. Among the entire Three Kingdoms, only Sima Yi did it. And among the entire actors, only Ni Dahong showed it. So I prefer the new Three Kingdoms a little bit.
-
I feel that the old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is better-looking, and the production of the old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is more sophisticated, and it looks more immersive.
-
The old Three Kingdoms is better-looking, there are too many new Three Kingdoms dramas, too many ghosts, the scenes that should really be filmed have not been filmed, and there are too many episodes of the scenes that are not, this is a big mistake and mistake of the director, no level, I'm sorry for the original work and the audience who support this drama, I'm so disappointed.
-
I think the old Three Kingdoms are better-looking. First of all, the characters are classic. For example, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Cao Cao, Zhuge Liang, etc. completely crushed the New Three Kingdoms, followed by the storyline, and the characters' lines are better than the New Three Kingdoms.
-
I think the old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" looks better, the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is very classic, and it feels more like the new version.
-
The old Three Kingdoms are good-looking, the new Three Kingdoms are garbage, all kinds of mistakes in the play Take Cao Jie as an example, she said that she was Cao Pi's sister for a while, and she became a sister again for a while, what else is Xuzhou City the first Xiongguan in the Central Plains Does Xuzhou have Xuzhou City? Is it related to the Central Plains? Cao Shuang's talent is far above his father, playing Cao Zhen as a fool, seven captures of Meng Hou, Jiang Wei's nine expeditions to the Central Plains, these plots are not there, there are too many slots, I can't bear to look at it directly, and the actors are also sparse.
-
The old version is better than the new version in any aspect, and the new version is Zhang Fei, not to mention anything else, is completely a black impermanence in black and white.
-
The old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is better-looking, and the feeling of the old version and the new version is completely different, and the actors of the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms are also very good.
-
The old version looks good. Although the props are not as good as the modern ones, and the picture quality is not clear enough, the characters are restored very well.
-
It is by no means "preconceived", the old version of the Three Kingdoms is much better than the new version of the Three Kingdoms.
To be honest: I only watched two or three episodes of the new version of the Three Kingdoms and didn't watch it, first of all, I don't like his character modeling, it looks very twisted.
I am a "fan of the Three Kingdoms", although I have read the "Three Kingdoms" more than 700 times compared to the master Mr. Su Wenmao, but I have also heard the story of the "Three Kingdoms" from my parents since I was a child.
In 1976, I named my only son a figure of the Three Kingdoms.
The new version of the Three Kingdoms is not as good as the old version of the Three Kingdoms in other aspects, I will be too lazy to say.
Turnip and cabbage, each with its own love. Let's have our opinions!
-
For the characters, the new "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is more delicate. For example, Sun Quan's deprivation of Zhou Yu's power was more suitable for showing the identity of the emperor.
-
"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is relatively concise, but it is too rigid in **, and Cao Cao played by Bao Guoan is the biggest highlight of the whole play!
The characters in "Three Kingdoms" are richer, and the scenes are good-looking, but most of the characters in the play talk nonsense, and those big characters seem to be stupid, as if they are afraid that others will not know what he is thinking, such as Cao Cao, the character is nagging and nagging and can't hide secrets in his heart. Even the phrase "coercing the Son of Heaven to order the princes" was even said to others, and a character with extremely deep scheming and incomparably scheming turned into a fool!
-
I think the old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is better-looking, because the actors in it are all powerful actors, and their acting skills are very good.
-
The old version is a little better, because the old version is for the sake of feelings, and the new printmaking style is a bit ruin to childhood.
-
The old Three Kingdoms has a strong sense of substitution, and the shape of the new Three Kingdoms (such as Zhang Fei) and the endless nonsense are all big heads, and the two are not comparable.
-
can't be compared,,Can't be compared, The biggest failure of the New Three Kingdoms is Zhuge Liang played by Lu Yi. It's too bad.
-
Old "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", I prefer to watch this Romance of the Three Kingdoms because it feels particularly age-sensitive, and it is also very similar to what happened at that time.
-
Gao Dao is amazing! The ** party and the history party have never been incompatible, until Gao Dao tightly unites them together, regardless of previous suspicions, seeking common ground while reserving differences, having common goals, common enemies, and people filming the Three Kingdoms drama either based on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, or based on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, with some artistic creations in between! Gao Dao is very powerful, using wild history and the world as the basis for new languages, with a little Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Three Kingdoms in between.
-
The 94 version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is indeed an unprecedented classic, with lines, actions, makeup, and scenes that are relatively close to ancient times. The filming of the New Three Kingdoms is a mess, I watched a few episodes and stopped watching it, it doesn't fit the ancient style at all, and filming the New Three Kingdoms is a waste of money
-
The new Three Kingdoms are good-looking, and they are fans of Cao Cheng.
-
The old version focuses on "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the original, "New Three Kingdoms" restores the real history of the Three Kingdoms, and portrays more characters.
-
The old version is good-looking, and so is the Red Mansion.
-
The old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is simply a documentary made by the crew back to the Three Kingdoms era! As for the new Three Kingdoms, don't mention it, just forget about the shape of the thunder people!
-
I like the classical Chinese dialogue of the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
-
The casting of the new Three Kingdoms is really... That Ma Chao and Zhou Yu are more like one to eat. The lines are also crotch-pulling, like a child's bickering.
-
Hesitation is disrespectful to the old version.
-
The New Three Kingdoms is more like a martial arts drama.
-
The old version of martial arts would be more perfect if it was a little more refined.
-
Take a look at the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".It is irrefutable that the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" can be said to be the theme of an era, which fully reflects the background of that era at that time, and the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is based on the original work, and there is relatively little tampering with the description in the book. Among them, the literary drama is also more exciting, after all, the classics are not so easy to surpass and break through. Whether it is in terms of plot or actors' acting skills, the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" still has his own characteristics.
The new version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".The new "Three Kingdoms" stands at a considerable historical height, and regards Cao, Liu, and Sun as heroes, heroes with different personalities, bearings, and styles. It does not simply affirm one side and negate one side, nor does it make one-sided articles about overturning the case. The new edition of "Three Kingdoms" sublimates the pursuit and celebration of ideal morality.
It also more fully embodied the most fundamental pursuit of that era: trying to give full play to one's own wisdom and talents to reunite the country. This is the core part of the ideological value of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and it is also the most important common cultural psychology of the Chinese nation.
Actually, I think the old version and the new version have their own characteristics. Different aesthetic tastes naturally have different preferences.
-
I think the old version is better, the plot is based on the original work, there are a lot of tamperings in the new version, a lot of them, the old version of the Three Kingdoms drama is good, the war scenes are indeed very weak, but the new version of the drama is too bad, just like a martial arts drama, there is nothing to see, the most annoying thing is that a lot of events have been omitted, the position has changed, and the characters have changed, just to save a few actors, it's really bad, the old version will have blood boiling and tears in your eyes when you look at it, but the new version doesn't. When I saw the old version of Guan Yu, I felt that this was what the original book looked like, and when I saw the new version of Guan Yu, I felt that I was just trying my best to imitate it. Also, why does Liu Bei in the new version look like a facial paralysis...
-
Although the Romance of the New Three Kingdoms did not surpass the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the Romance of the New Three Kingdoms also has a very high status in the minds of young audiences today, because the Romance of the New Three Kingdoms also gathered a large number of excellent actors at that time, and these actors also contributed very good acting skills and content.
-
In the 1994 version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Zhuge Liang's actor Tang Guoqiang is also a Taurus. The actors in the new version don't look very much like the ancients, and they don't have the simple temperament of the ancients, even if the modern shooting technology is very developed, but the things in the bones are not expressed, so they can't be compared with the old version of 94, and the classics can't be surpassed.
-
The remakes of countless classics show that classics cannot be surpassed and broken through.
Whether it is from the plot or the acting skills of the actors, the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is good-looking, the new version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has slightly tampered with history, and some details still need to be verified.
The actor of Sun Quan in the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is Wu Xiaodong. Born in 1961 in Chengde, Hebei Province, he graduated from the directing department of ** Drama Academy and worked as an actor and director in Chinese mainland. He joined the crew of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" in 1990, not only as the executive director, but also played the roles of Sun Jian and Sun Quan.
If you evaluate it by whether it looks good or not, it must be "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" that is slightly better. "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a type of history book, of course, it is not as good as **. >>>More
Episode 58. Xenomorph Invasion is a "redemption story with death as the starting point" with "killing intent" and "love" as the core, with Ming Akiren as the protagonist, with the "detective" investigating the world of killing intent as the bright line, and the wrestling between Hayase Ura and the Statue Girl as the dark line.
The Romance of the Three Kingdoms reflects a wealth of historical content, with character names, geographical names, and major events basically the same as those of the Three Kingdoms. The character is also replayed on the basis of the fixed image left by "Three Kingdoms", which is also the routine of historical romance. Historical romance** is mostly between the virtual and the real, and the main reality is heavy on the virtual; Taking into account the ancient and the modern, criticizing the past and judging the present; A story that tells the love of the two dynasties, a character, and the sex of the two dynasties. >>>More
I should be able to write about my feelings after reading in elementary school, and I appreciate Guan Yu's righteousness, Zhang Fei's bravery, Zhuge Liang's resourcefulness and heartfelt devotion to the lord. Then on why you like them, you can give some specific examples.