How do you view the prosperity of the Han and Tang dynasties? What is the difference between the pro

The prosperous era of the Han and Tang dynasties was the first period of the development of feudal society in ancient China. Its politics are clear, the officialdom is clean, and the rulers are open-minded and good at knowing people and doing their jobs. **The functions of the department are clear and the work efficiency is high.

As a result, the people can live and work in peace and contentment, relatively speaking, there is no harsh taxes and miscellaneous taxes, and the people live more easily.

In terms of diplomacy, the status is high, and the surrounding countries have to learn and pay tribute, and they are all vassal states.

It is militarily strong, with a strong army to defend the country's territorial security.

The Han Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty are two of the most powerful periods in the history of our country, and they are also the most well-known dynasties in China in the world, so now we call ourselves Han Chinese, while the West calls us Tang people, and in major cities in the West, the place where the Chinese gather is called Chinatown.

The Han dynasty reached its peak during the reign of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, while the Tang dynasty reached its peak of strength during the reign of Emperor Xuanzong of the Tang dynasty. At the peak of these national powers, our country often attacked from all directions, expanded its territory, and expelled those foreigners who repeatedly invaded our territory. In the Han Dynasty, Wei Qing, Huo Quzhi, Li Guang and other famous generals attacked and killed the Xiongnu in a sung and lamentable history, and left behind the famous sentence full of pride and domineering "Those who commit me to be a strong man, although they are far away, will be punished".

The Tang Dynasty completely defeated the Eastern and Western Turks and truly incorporated a large area of northern territory into China's territory.

One can't help but wonder which of the two most powerful dynasties in Chinese history was stronger? This question can be compared mainly in terms of territory and economic power.

As can be seen from the territory map above, the territory of the Tang Dynasty was much broader. In terms of economic aggregate, the GDP of the Tang Dynasty accounted for 58% of the world's GDP at that time, and it was the absolute giant of the world at that time, while the Han Dynasty was 26%, although the proportion was smaller, but it was also one of the best in the world at that time, and the ancient Roman Empire was neck and neck, ruling the East and the West respectively.

The Han and Tang dynasties were one of the strongest and most powerful historical stages in the world, when we were the most powerful country in the world, the people were happy, the country was stable, and it was also the pinnacle of the ancient Han nation.

Such a dynasty must have been very prosperous, and the people's lives at that time were also very happy, because of some officials, as well as the emperor's wise decision-making, the local economy will develop very well.

The prosperity of the Han and Tang dynasties was one of the most prosperous historical periods of culture and economy. Many excellent poets were born, and the economy developed rapidly. A lot of precious historical materials have been left behind. It was also one of the most powerful periods.

The prosperous era of the Han and Tang dynasties was the Han Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty, when the martial arts and international prestige were relatively strong, so people refer to the prosperous era of the Han and Tang dynasties as the prosperous era of the Han and Tang dynasties.

The Western Han Dynasty, the Tang Dynasty, and the early Qing Dynasty were the three major dynasties in Chinese history.

In the history of China's reform of Bichong, there are unified dynasties such as Qin, Han, Sui, Tang, Song, Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties, and there have been more than 10 prosperous eras, and the most famous prosperous era is only three times, that is, from the rule of Wenjing to the extreme prosperity of Emperor Wu and then to the prosperity of the Western Han Dynasty of Zhaoxuan Zhongxing, from the rule of Zhenguan to the prosperity of the Tang Dynasty of Kaiyuan and the prosperity of the early Qing Dynasty of the Kang Yongqian period.

The prosperity of the Western Han Dynasty included the rule of Wenjing, the extreme prosperity of Emperor Wu and then the prosperity of Zhaoxuan Zhongxing, which lasted for 130 years. Achievements of this period:

1. Emperor Wen and Emperor Jing recuperated, the treasury was sufficient, the grain was piled up outside the warehouse and rotted, and the people were rich;

2. After Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, he expanded his territory, defeated the powerful Xiongnu, and included the Western Regions in the first territory. The Lingnan region, the Northeast and other regions have also been expanded.

3. "Historical Records" and "Hanshu" created historiography, ideology and culture, and all of them are moving towards prosperity and developed science and technology.

If it is a longitudinal comparison of history, the present is of course far more than any past period, including the Han and Tang dynasties. Whether it is culture, science and technology, education, or many other aspects, they are incomparable to the Han and Tang dynasties.

However, if we compare horizontally, we really do not have the same status in today's world as it did in the Tang Dynasty. Although in the more than 30 years of reform and opening up, we have developed by leaps and bounds, made remarkable achievements, and continuously improved our international status. It should be admitted, however, that there is still a gap between China and the developed countries in terms of science and technology, culture and education, and comprehensive strength.

Only by guarding against arrogance and rashness, constantly forging ahead, and constantly narrowing the gap between us and the developed countries, can we finally catch up with and surpass them and gain a higher international status.

Domestically, it is almost the same as the prosperity of the Han and Tang dynasties, but in terms of international status, the Han and Tang dynasties are even beyond the reach of the current United States.

No, in the Han and Tang dynasties, all countries came to the dynasty, and culture and art deeply influenced Japan, South Korea, and Southeast Asia.

Far from the economy, the Han Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty had several famous prosperous eras in history (Wenjing, Zhaoxuan Zhongxing, Kaiyuan, Zhenguan, etc.), the Han Dynasty was due to the unified issuance of the national currency in the second dynasty, it could not be more than now, and there was no currency in the early Sui and Tang dynasties with brocade silk as currency. The economy is not comparable.

Most of the land of China today inherited the land area of the late Qing Dynasty, but the overall area cannot be compared with the Han and Tang dynasties in the strong period. At least Outer Mongolia, North Korea, and Vietnam are completely independent.

Humanistic comparison, the Chinese in the Han and Tang dynasties advocated force and were proud of bravery, and one Han Dynasty soldier was more than five Hun soldiers during the Han Dynasty, which shows how enthusiastic the Chinese people were about war at that time. During the Tang Dynasty, we had just come from the Northern and Southern Dynasties, and the blood of the people at that time was mixed with the blood of Hulu, and they were even more heroic and warlike. At that time, they were invincible.

Its population naturally cannot be compared with the current population, but the Chinese in the Han and Tang dynasties were fierce and brave and warlike, far from being comparable to the current Han people.

The Han and Tang dynasties were a period of outward expansion of Chinese culture, and various countries sent students to China to learn advanced culture. There was once a country in China that sent students to China.

The foreign wars of the Han and Tang dynasties affected the whole world, the Han Dynasty attacked the Xiongnu in the west, and drove the Xiongnu to Europe, and the Europeans at that time called these Xiongnu people "the whip of God", and they turned Europe upside down at that time, and the whole period was called the "Dark Ages". The Tang Dynasty attacked the Turkic tribes in the north and drove the Turkic tribes to what is now Central Asia, and its descendants established the Ottoman Turkish Empire, which became a nightmare for Europe.

Especially during the Han and Tang dynasties, there were endless military generals that we still admire today. Wei Qing, Huo Quzhi, Chen Tang, Li Shiji, Xue Rengui, Gao Xianzhi, etc.

What's even more exciting is that Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty went west for a few horses, which really boosted the morale of the Chinese people. Whatever you are asked to pay tribute, you will pay tribute, or I will beat you. Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty marched into the Western Regions for the sake of sweat and blood, seemingly for his own pleasure, but in fact to improve the quality of Chinese horses and maintain the dignity of the country.

History cannot be indulged

to than, because this will make you have a serious delusion, than.

The ancients didn't.

According to these products of rapid industrialization that make you think that your life today is definitely better than that of the ancients, and you forget that you still can't afford to buy a house or pay off your credit card. The longitudinal ratio is definitely better than anything in the Han and Tang Dynasties, after all, the industrial civilization is not negotiable, and the agricultural civilization is not negotiable.

The Han Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty had several famous prosperous eras in history (Wenjing, Zhaoxuan Zhongxing, Kaiyuan, Zhenguan, etc.), and the Han Dynasty was due to the unified issuance of the national currency as the second dynasty, which could not be more than now.

As far as the current international position is concerned, it is far inferior to the Han and Tang Dynasties. The Han and Tang dynasties are hundreds of years ahead of other dao nations and countries, and now we are dozens or even hundreds of years (different fields) after the fall. As far as people's livelihood is concerned, because we don't know the situation in ancient times, but the material should be richer now, after all, the times have developed, and many other aspects are not heavy on quality and scale.

Generally speaking, it should be called a quasi-prosperous era, and it is on the road to entering the prosperous era.

The material living standards of the people today are still higher than those of the Tang Dynasty. At least, now the Chinese can squeeze the bus when they go out of the special line, but they can squeeze the train; At that time, people could only ride ox carts and donkeys. The food and drink were also better than in those days, when people only ate two meals and monks only ate one; And now monks can drive BMWs and marry daughters-in-law.

In terms of international status, Tang Sanzang took a passport and ran all over the world, and when people saw that it was from the Tang Dynasty, they were very respectful; Now Chinese people want to go to some European countries, waiting for visas can wait until their heads are white.

At that time, Japan did not dare to talk about the Diaoyu Islands, and often sent students to China to study and send envoys to pay tribute.

During the period of Taizong of the Tang Dynasty, it was the largest land area in China's history, and there were many vassal countries around, and the culture was also very open, and Tang poetry was a treasure of Chinese culture

There is no comparison, now China's largest ethnic group still calls itself Han nationality, the national costume of the Han nation is still proud of the Tang costume, and now it is an ID card and does not dare to call the People's Republic of China citizen ID card, but called the resident ID card, do you say that there is such a prosperous era when the people are like a turtle with a shrunken head? !

The land area, population, and economy of the Han and Tang dynasties were completely exploded. Influence··· Almost. Militarily, the Han and Xiongnu lost more than they won, and the Xiongnu were finally dragged to death by the Han Empire's foreign policy and repeated fights and civil strife.

Tang and Turkic and Tibetan that are called a tangled. It seems that this dynasty has not been significantly defeated militarily, and it has fought against both superpowers, and it has also withheld. In this way, militarily, the dynasty is not bad.

China now has nothing but population and total economic leadership, and its current economic leadership is also due to cheap labor, which was not the case during the Han and Tang dynasties.

It's far from it, that's the dignified China that wants the Quartet to congratulate it.

In my opinion, it can't catch up with the Tang Dynasty, that is, although China is not rich, but it is also the dynasty of all countries.

Not a little worse. But now China is not a prosperous era in the eyes of many people, but a prosperous and prosperous (n prosperous (n prosperous times are omitted here).

In the Han and Tang dynasties, China was a world power, but now China is indeed a developing country and is left behind by Western countries, so it should not be called a prosperous era compared with the Han and Tang dynasties.

It can't be called, because the prosperity includes a full range of political, economic, technological, cultural, military and other things. The Tang Dynasty was hundreds of years higher than the world in all aspects, and how does China compare now!

During the Tang Dynasty, foreigners came to study in China, and now Chinese go to study abroad. People's living standards have risen, and China's international status is completely inferior to the past.

There are pros and cons to each other, and today's society is more legal and digital.

Can't compare! During the Tang Dynasty, Chang'an and Rome were as famous in the world, and now Beijing is not ranked high.

There was a certain gap in international status, and it was the undisputed number one country at that time, and culturally it was far less prosperous than it was at that time, and it was much better than it was at that time in terms of people's living standards, because the times had developed.

It's nothing, it can only be said that it is more open and civilized than the surrounding countries, which is equivalent to the United States today compared to other countries.

The economy is prosperous, the people are prosperous, and the country is stable.

There is no way to make a comprehensive comparison between two different eras, after all, human history is constantly changing.

Compared with the present, there are only two points that are incomparable in the Tang Dynasty, one is the territorial area, and the other is the poetry culture.

Nothing else can be better than it is now.

During the Tang Dynasty, the territory was the largest during the reign of Emperor Gaozong of the Tang Dynasty, with an area of about 18 million square kilometers (15.76 million square kilometers).

During the reign of Tang Taizong and Tang Gaozong, they continued to fight against the Turkic, Xue Yantuo, Tuyuhun, and Western Regions states (Gaochang, Qiuzi, etc.) and eliminated these regimes, thus gradually controlling the southern part of the country, the northern part of the country, and the Western Regions.