There is a sentence in Short Song Xing , why does Liu Fu say that it is an unlucky word?

What is the explanation of "bad words"? I think it's based on a purely literal understanding. "Three turns around the tree, what branches can follow" embodies "homelessness", which is equivalent to "the dog that lost its home".

In Chinese literature, "the dog that lost its home" is often used to describe people who are depressed and lose their power and run away in defeat, such as "anxious like a lost dog, hurried like a fish that has slipped through the net" and so on. And in fact, in "Romance", Cao Cao.

After the defeat, it was indeed so, and was several times by Soochow and Liu Bei.

intercepted, did not dare to go to Nanjun, did not dare to go to Gangneung, the loss of soldiers and generals was indeed like a "lost dog", fulfilling his "proverb". —There are many "proverbs" of this nature in Kyauk's "Romance", and it can be regarded as a literary style led by it.

"Bright as the moon" or "bright as the moon", both can be. In the process of copying ancient poems, due to various reasons, such as typos and false transmission in the process of oral transmission, there are often several different versions of the same poem. A typical example of this is Su Dongpo.

The big river goes east, in which the sentence "rocks collapse clouds and waves crash on the shore" also has a version written "rocks pierce the air". The question you asked also falls into this category. What Cao Cao wants to express:

Three turns around the tree, there are no branches to follow". The "tree" in "Three Turns Around the Tree" refers to Sun Wu at that time.

The "branch" in "no branch to follow" refers to Sun Wu's combat effectiveness at that time. After Cao Cao specifically referred to Liu Bei as a "weak" black magpie, he went on to compare Sun Wu to a "branchless" tree. It means that Liu Bei didn't rely on Sun Wu?

But Sun Wu also didn't have much combat effectiveness, so he couldn't let Liu Bei rely on him.

In Cao Cao's view, the situation at that time was already very favorable to him, as long as he could take Jiangdong (Sun Wu), the unification of the world was just around the corner. "Tanka Xing".

It epitomizes his response to the "Battle of Red Cliffs."

The determination to win, and use this to motivate his soldiers.

What I said above is very reasonable, very in line with the context of the time, I am silent...

The enthusiast above said it right, I don't have anything to say.

It should be pointed out that in history, Cao Cao did not kill Liu Fu, and Liu Fu died of natural causes. Liu Fu and Cao Cao still have some friendship.

The moon stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south. Three turns around the tree, what branches can be followed. It is a poem from Cao Cao's "Short Song Xing".

In fact, it is inconclusive when and where this poem was written, so "Killer Pain" and "Bad Words" are fictional details of Cao Cao's cruelty and self-use in "Romance".

In terms of the understanding of "Romance" alone, in order to render the "fruit" of Cao Cao's future Chibi fiasco, a very mystical "cause" was created here in literature - Cao Cao himself uttered a "proverb" of "bad luck", which foreshadowed the great defeat in the future - this kind of literary creation technique is very traditional Chinese characteristics: "karma" and "philosophy of prophecy".

So, what is the meaning of "bad words"? I think it's based on a purely literal understanding. "Three turns around the tree, what branches can follow" embodies "homelessness", which is equivalent to "the dog that lost its home".

In Chinese literature, "the dog that lost its home" is often used to describe people who are depressed and lose their power and run away in defeat, such as "anxious like a lost dog, hurried like a fish that has slipped through the net" and so on. In fact, in "Romance", Cao Cao was indeed like this after his defeat, he was intercepted by Dongwu and Liu Bei several times, did not dare to go to Nanjun, did not dare to go to Jiangling, and lost his troops and generals were indeed like "lost dogs", fulfilling his "proverbs". - There are many "proverbs" of this nature in "Romance", and it can be regarded as a literary style led by it.

There is a character in the TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", who is a musician. After Cao Cao wrote the poem "Short Song Xing" in Henghua, he asked the teacher to comment. The teacher said:

Although the lyrics of the prime minister are world-famous, it is just that Yale should be 'righteous and peaceful' and 'elegant and pure', but there are ominous words ...... in the tankaThe moon stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south. Three turns around the tree, no branches to follow' these sentences are not in line with the norms of Yale, but also very unlucky! At present, the southern expedition is imminent, and when the army is about to fight, such ominous words will damage the prestige of the army! Cao Cao was furious and said:

Ann dares to defeat my poetry? Then he raised a lance in his hand and killed Shi Miao. The next day, Cao Cao cried and said:

Yesterday, I was drunk and accidentally injured my teacher, and I felt deeply guilty. Shi Miao is a generation of musicians, and since then there has been no elegant sound in the world. Alas, there is no time to regret!

After that, Cao Cao ordered someone to bury the teacher. Although in the original work of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is no teacher, but there is one person in a similar situation, this person is Liu Fu. According to the records of "Three Kingdoms, Volume 15, Wei Shu 15", Liu Fu was a native of Peiguo and served as the assassin of Yangzhou.

In the forty-eighth episode of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", "Banquet on the Yangtze River, Cao Cao's Fu Poem, Lock the Warship and the Northern Military Force", Cao Cao Heng wrote the poem "Short Song Xing", "After the song, everyone and it, everyone laughed." Suddenly, a person came in and said: 'When the army is equal, when the soldiers are using their lives, why did the prime minister make such an inauspicious remark?

it, it is the history of Yangzhou Thorn, Pei Guoxiang, surnamed Liu, the name Fu, and the word Yuanying. Fu started from Heqi, founded the state governance, gathered the fleeing people, established a school, Guangtuntian, Xingzhi Teaching, Cao Cao for a long time, and made many meritorious achievements. At the moment, Cao Heng asked and said:

What's wrong with my words? Fu said: "The moon and stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south; Three turns around the tree, there are no branches to follow".

This is also an inauspicious statement. Cao was furious and said: "Ru'an dares to defeat Wuxing!"

With a hammer in his hand, he stabbed Liu Fu to death. Everyone was horrified. Then the feast was dismissed.

The next day, I woke up drunk, and I was full of regret. Liu Xi, the son, asked his father's body to be buried. crying:

I accidentally injured your father yesterday because I was drunk, and I have no regrets. It can be buried with three public rites. He also sent a sergeant to escort the coffin and return it for burial on the same day.

It can be seen from this that the teacher in the TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" should be fictionalized by the director, and his original form in the original work is actually Liu Fu. Although the analysis of the cause of Liu Fu's death through "Tanka Xing" is only a hypothesis, this historical fact is not recorded in the official history. However, this does not prove that the claim that Liu Fu died because of "Tanka Xing" is not valid.

First, "Zizhi Tongjian, Volume 65" records that Cao Cao marched south to Liu Biao in July of the thirteenth year of Jian'an. In October of the same year, Cao Cao went east from Jiangling along the river, and then met Wu Jun in Chibi.

This shows that the "Battle of Red Cliffs" did indeed take place in the thirteenth year of Jian'an. Both: According to the records of "Three Kingdoms, Volume 15, Wei Shu 15":

Liu Fu died in the thirteenth year of Jian'an, and it is not impossible that he died in the "Battle of Red Cliffs". Three: In the Renjiao edition of "Appreciation of the Translation of Ancient High School Poems" (Volume 3) and "High School Chinese Volume 3" (new textbook), there are "Tanka Xing" annotations when Cao operated in the "Battle of Red Cliffs" in the thirteenth year of Jian'an.

We believe that the story of Cao Cao's poems and then killing Liu Fu is not impossible to verify, but it is not impossible.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is said that Cao Cao killed Liu Fu.

In fact, this person was appointed by Cao Cao to be the assassin of Yangzhou, who had made great contributions to building the city and raising the people in Hefei, but he contracted typhoid fever and died soon after the Battle of Chibi. However, because of his performance, Sun Quan personally led his men and horses to attack Hefei but could not attack it for a long time, and when Yangzhou did not drive Jiang Ji (the Jiang Taiwei who later launched the Gaopingling Incident with Sima Yi) was in a hurry, he deliberately sent out the military report that Cao Cao sent troops to rescue Hefei with three people, and falsely claimed that the number of 4,000 was 40,000, and Sun Quan's plan to retreat and cooperate with Zhou Yu to attack Jiangling also failed after intercepting false information.

Zhang Liao's later ability to inflict heavy losses on Sun Quan in Xiaoyaojin also stemmed from Liu Fu's family background of building cities and hoarding grain, so that he and Li Dian and Le Jin could make an appointment with Sun Quan.

Eighty or one-ninth of the troops held Hefei.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Fu was killed, and there is no teacher in **, and Shi Miao is a character in the TV series.

Yangzhou Thorn History, Pei Guoxiangren, surname Liu, name Fu, character Yuan.

Ying Cao Cao was laughing and talking, when he suddenly heard the crow's prestige flying away. Cao asked; "Why does this crow chirp at night? Left and right replied:

When the crow saw the moon, it was suspected that it was dawn, so it was away from the tree and chirped. "and laugh. When he was drunk, he took the lance and stood on the bow of the ship with wine.

Laid in the middle of the river, full of three jukes, the horizontal lance said to the generals: "I hold this lance, break the yellow scarf, capture Lu Bu, destroy Yuan Shu, collect Yuan Shao, deep."

Entering the north, reaching Liaodong, crisscrossing the world: quite worthy of the ambition of the husband. Today, there is great generosity in this situation. I will sing as a song, Thou.

and so on. The song said: "When you sing about wine, life is geometric: for example, the morning dew is bitter in the past." Be generous, and worry is unforgettable; What.

To solve worries, only Du Kang. Qingqing Zijin, leisurely my heart; But for the sake of the king, he has been groaning so far. Yo yo deer chirping, eating wild apples; I.

There are guests, drummers and shengs. Bright as the moon, when can I drop out? Worries come from it, and you can't cut it off! The more strange it is, the more vain it exists; Contract.

Talk about the feast, and remember the old kindness. The moon stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south. Three turns around the tree, there are no branches to follow". The mountains are not tired of being high, and the water is not tired of being deep: Zhou.

The public vomits and feeds, and the world returns to the heart. "At the end of the song, everyone laughs and laughs. Suddenly, a person entered the seat and said, "When the army is quite large, soldiers."

When he used his life, why did the prime minister make such an unlucky statement? "Regard it, it is the history of Yangzhou Thorn, Pei Guoxiang, surnamed Liu, named Fu, and the character.

Glume. Fu started from Heqi, founded the state governance, gathered the fleeing people, established a school, Guangtuntian, Xingzhi Teaching, Cao Cao for a long time, and made many meritorious contributions.

Performance. At that moment, Cao Hengqi asked: "What's wrong with my words?" Fu said: "The moon and stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south; Three turns around the tree, no branches.

Followable. This is also an inauspicious statement. Cao was furious and said: "Ru'an dares to defeat Wuxing!" With a hammer in his hand, he stabbed Liu Fu to death. Everyone was horrified.

Then the feast was dismissed. The next day, I woke up drunk, and I was full of regret. Liu Xi, the son, asked his father's body to be buried. Cao wept and said: "I accidentally injured you yesterday because I was drunk.

Father, there is no way to regret it. It can be buried with three public rites. He also sent a sergeant to escort the coffin and return it for burial on the same day.

Be. It seems that Chen Shou still doesn't know whose it is?

It is a person whose position is to sacrifice wine for the military advisor.

Meaning: The moonlight is bright and the stars are sparse, and a group of nest-seeking black magpies fly south. Flew around the tree for three weeks but didn't collect their wings, ** to have a place for them to live? It implies that the future of the Three Kingdoms is bleak, and they don't know where to go, and it is difficult to achieve hegemony. This is also the reason why Cao Cao said that this was an inauspicious word.

From: "Tanka Xing" is a poem written by Cao Cao, a politician and writer in the late Han Dynasty, with the ancient theme of Yuefu.

Original: tanka line.

Two Hans: Cao Cao.

When you sing about wine, life is geometric! For example, the morning dew is bitter in the past.

Be generous, and worry is unforgettable; How to solve the problem? Only Du Kang.

Qingqing Zijin, leisurely my heart; But for the sake of the king, he has been groaning so far.

Yo yo deer chirping, eating wild apples; I have guests, drummers and shengs.

It's as clear as the moon, when can it be done? Worries come from it, and you can't cut it off!

The more strange it is, the more vain it exists; Talking about the old kindness.

The moon stars are scarce, and the black magpie flies south. Three turns around the tree, what branches can be followed.

The mountains are not tired of being high, and the sea is not tired of being deep. Zhou Gong vomited and fed, and the world returned to the heart.

Translation: Drinking and singing at the same time, how many years of life are there.

It's like the morning dew is fleeting, and there are so many times that have passed!

The singing at the banquet was impassioned, but the sorrow in my heart was unforgettable.

What can be used to relieve boredom? Only booze on good wine.

O learned men, you make me longing for you.

It's just because of you that I've been chanting so much.

In the sun, the deer roared and ate mugwort in the field.

Once the talents from all over the world come to the house, I will play the sheng and feast the guests.

When can you pick up the bright moon hanging in the air?

The deep worries in my heart gushed out and could not be stopped.

Guests from afar crossed the fields and drove to visit me.

Reunite with each other after a long absence, talk about heart-to-heart feasts, and relive the kindness of the past.

The moonlight was bright and the stars were sparse, and a group of nesting black magpies flew south.

Flew around the tree for three weeks but didn't collect their wings, ** to have a place for them to live?

The mountains are majestic only when the earth and rocks are not abandoned, and the sea is magnificent when the trickle is not abandoned.

I would like to be like the corporal of Zhou Gong, and I hope that the heroes of the world will sincerely obey me.

The moonlight was so bright that the starlight was dim. A flock of crows flew south, circling the trees for three weeks, but could not find a place for them. It implies that the future of the Three Kingdoms is bleak, and they don't know where to go, and it is difficult to achieve hegemony. Seek adoption.

This is fake, there is no one in history, it is made up in the romance.

It is estimated that it reflects his forgetfulness before the war, laying the groundwork for the subsequent defeat.

It was Cao Cao's musician Shi Xun.