If Sun Quan gave the living Guan Yu to Cao Cao instead of the head, what would happen to Guan Yu?

Cao Cao will release Guan Yu, because Guan Yu will also let Cao Cao go, and they will cherish each other, but Cao Cao will encourage Guan Yu to recapture Jingzhou. After Guan Yu goes back, he will ask to attack Wu to recapture Jingzhou, and he will be ashamed, and Liu Bei also thinks that he has no face for losing Jingzhou. But Zhuge Liang thought that he should go on a northern expedition, so there was a war of words, and no one was able to defeat him.

Liu Bei will still go on a northern expedition.

Guan Yu will end up alive, because Cao Cao will never kill him, and he may be let go.

Guan Yu and Liu Bei Taoyuan formed a righteous alliance, and they would not betray Liu Bei no matter what. If Sun Quan hadn't killed Guan Yu at the beginning, Cao Cao wouldn't have been able to make Guan Yu submit. The final outcome was either that Guan Yu returned to Liu Bei alive, or that Guan Yu was killed by Cao Cao.

Guan Yu should not die, and Cao Cao will persuade him to surrender, because Guan Yu is Cao Cao's most important person.

Because Cao Cao is very talented, Cao Cao saved Guan Yu's life and regarded him as a brother.

In order to show himself, he feels that he can make others think that he is strong by doing so, and that he has the ability to kill others.

Because in this way, Liu Bei would not attack Eastern Wu. Will attack Cao Cao.

If Sun Quan captures Guan Yu alive and gives it to Cao Cao, then I think Cao Cao is actually more difficult to choose. Although Cao Cao likes Guan Yu very much, Guan Yu did bring a lot of trouble to Cao Cao, and it also made him quite jealous. Faced with this situation, I think Cao Cao may have 4 options.

Cao Cao is very likely to release Guan Yu directly, because Cao Cao knows that if Guan Yu returns to Shu Han, then he must want to continue to fight against Dongwu, after all, Guan Yu is also a very arrogant person, he was captured alive by Dongwu, according to the nature of Guan Yu, he will definitely not be able to swallow this breath. At this time, Cao Cao could just sit on the mountain and watch the tiger fight, and when Dongwu and Shu Han fought each other, he could just sit and reap the benefits of the fisherman. <>

If Dongwu was really able to capture Guan Yu alive and give Guan Yu to Cao Cao, then Cao Cao might also kill Guan Yu directly. After all, for Cao Cao, Guan Yu is indeed a very big threat, and if this threat can be solved, it will be a good thing. But if Guan Yu is really killed, then Cao Cao must be prepared to accept Liu Bei's revenge, and Liu Bei will inevitably do everything he has to take revenge on Cao Cao.

I think this possibility may be greater, because whether you directly release Guan Yu or kill Guan Yu directly, there will be some more serious consequences. But if Guan Yu is directly put under house arrest, it is a very useful method, although Guan Yu is put under house arrest, Cao Cao will always treat him with good food and drink, so that he will not completely offend Liu Bei, and even after a long time, it is possible to let Guan Yu work for himself again. <>

This possibility is also relatively large, if Sun Quan gave Guan Yu to Cao Cao, it was actually to lead the troubled water to Cao Wei. Cao Cao, who is so smart, can naturally see it, so it is wisest to return Guan Yu to Sun Quan at this time.

Cao Cao will be very happy to harvest a fierce general like Guan Yu. But Sun Quan will also offend Liu Bei because of this.

Cao Cao is likely to release Guan Yu and then continue to fight against Eastern Wu, thus effectively realizing his own value, and of course he may also kill him, but the probability of such a is very small.

If you give it to Cao Cao, it won't have much impact, because Cao Cao is a person who cherishes talents very much, and he won't have too many bad actions towards Guan Yu.

During the Three Kingdoms period, Eastern Wu and Shu Han jointly resisted Cao, and later Shu Han occupied Yizhou and Hanzhong, Jingzhou Guan Yu in order to expand the territory, attacked Xiangfan's Cao army, at that time Eastern Wu thought that the development of Shu Han would be unfavorable to Eastern Wu, so privately united with Cao Cao, sneak attack Jingzhou, Guan Yu was defeated by the enemy at that time and took Maicheng, was captured by Eastern Wu and killed. After Guan Yu's death, Sun Quan put Guan Yu's head in a box and sent someone to give it to Cao Cao. So why did Sun Quan give his head to Cao Cao when he killed Guan Yu?

Sun Quan did this to make Shu Han understand that he killed Guan Yu to obey Cao Cao's orders, not his own will, and wanted to blame Cao Cao.

I want to blame Cao Cao. Let Liu Bei hate Cao Cao, causing a conflict between Cao Wei and Shu, although Sun Quan seized Jingzhou, he did not want to cause a war with Shu.

Cao Cao will not kill Guan Yu, but will treat him with courtesy, but Guan Yu should not think about returning to Shu to take revenge, although Cao Cao will not kill him, but he will definitely imprison him, after all, the battle of Fancheng Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army and shocked China, resulting in Pang De being killed, Cao Cao, as their lord, will not let the tiger return to the mountain even if he does not take revenge.

Cao Cao and Guan Yu have known each other for decades, and Cao Cao saw Guan Yu as a knife and axe player when the Tiger Prison Guan Alliance, but he thought that Guan Yu was extraordinary, and he also warmed wine for him, and later Liu Guanzhang's three brothers were separated, Guan Yu was captured by Cao Cao, Cao Cao not only did not embarrass him, but he was about three chapters with him, and he was entertained with good wine and food every day, and he would think about him when he had food, and even gave him Lu Bu's red rabbit horse.

But Guan Yu thought of Liu Bei, and later passed five passes and killed six generals Li Cao Cao, despite this, Cao Cao still wrote the customs clearance paperwork, and let Guan Yu leave, which shows that Cao Cao is very respectful to Guan Yu.

After the Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao was defeated, and Guan Yu was ordered to ambush Huarong Dao, but Guan Yu thought of salvation after seeing Cao Cao, so he let Cao Cao go, which shows that the two can be described as heroes. Cao Cao is very fond of Guan Yu, although it can't be used by me, but the spirit is worth learning from everyone, after Guan Yu came to Cao Cao's hands, Cao Cao cherished his talent on the one hand, and on the other hand, he repaid the grace of Huarong Dao, and he would not kill Guan Yu in a reasonable way. But if you don't kill Guan Yu, you will also impose more restrictions on him, it was his own indulgence back then, which led to the return of the tiger to the mountain, causing huge damage to himself, as the so-called eating a trench and growing wisdom, Cao Cao will never suffer this again.

Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army and shocked Huaxia, Cao Cao was so frightened that he almost moved the capital, Cao Cao would never be far away and let people go, in addition, why did Sun Quan rather risk offending Liu Bei to kill Guan Yu, and only gave Guan Yu the head after killing Guan Yu, because he was worried that Cao Cao would not be able to do it, resulting in him being chased and killed by Guan Yu in the future.

It should be taken care of, after all, Cao Cao is very suspicious, and he will definitely suspect Sun Quan's purpose in sending Guan Yu over.

Cao Cao values Guan Yu very much, so if Guan Yu is alive with Cao Cao, Cao Cao will definitely find a way to make Guan Yu loyal to him.

Cao Cao should first persuade Guan Yu to submit to him, and if Guan Yu is unwilling to die, he will kill him, and if he is willing, he will use it first.

It is estimated that Cao Cao will try to win over Guan Yu, because he admires Guan Yu very much, but if Guan Yu is unwilling, it is estimated that he will still be killed.

Cao Cao will put Guan Yu under house arrest, serve him with good food and drink until he is old, and Cao Cao will find Guan Yu to talk about world affairs when he has time.

Cao Cao attaches great importance to his reputation, Guan Yu is kind to him, he will definitely do everything possible to make Guan Yu loyal to him, if Guan Yu can't do it, it is estimated that he will be killed by Cao Cao.

Serving delicious food and drink, and chatting with him from time to time, after all, Cao Cao is very talented, and being able to use it for himself is his ultimate goal.

I don't think Cao Cao will kill Guan Yu, because Cao Cao himself admires Guan Yu more, and Guan Yu once saved his life.

Personally, I think that according to Cao Cao's behavior, Guan Yu will definitely be left behind, because Guan Yu once let himself go in the Battle of Chibi.

Yes, because Cao Cao cherishes such an excellent talent as Guan Yu very much, even if he knows that he will not surrender to himself, he will find a way to put him under house arrest and prevent him from returning to Shu Han for the time being.

If this is the case, then Cao Cao will definitely leave Guan Yu, because Cao Cao has always valued Guan Yu and admired Guan Yu's righteousness, and it is likely to change history at that time.

Yes, Cao Cao has always been very sorry for Guan Yu, he has wanted to include Guan Yu under his command several times, if so, he will definitely be able to save Guan Yu's life.

No, what Cao Cao wants is people's hearts, he will persuade Guan Yu to stay, but Guan Yu will also insist on leaving.

If he doesn't kill Guan Yu, will his old man survive?

If Sun Quan gave the living Guan Yu to Cao Cao, then Cao Cao would definitely try his best to let Guan Yu stay by his side, after all, Liu Bei is really hard to believe that he is a gentleman.

If Sun Quan pressed Guan Yu to Cao Cao, with the situation at the time, Cao Cao would not have done anything to Guan Yu, and would return Guan Yu to Liu Bei.

Cao Cao will let Guan Yu go, because Cao Cao still owes Guan Yu a favor, if Guan Yu does not let Cao Cao go in Huarong Dao, Cao Cao will be dead a long time ago.