Shutter Island, I hope there is a most reasonable answer

One of the most critical holes is that it can't explain that the protagonist sees that Rachel in the cave, so it's not true. And the conspiracy theory can solve all the confusion, so in favor of the conspiracy theory, that is, the hero is reshaped in memory. As for the last paragraph, the conspiracy theory still holds.

If you know the details, you can**.

The truth of "Shutter Island" is possible as follows:

1. If "George Noyce has delusions, and Dr. Rachel is really a person", it means that George has never left Shutter Island, and Ted has never left. And Dr. Rachel's statement is true, Shutter Island does engage in inhumane human experimentation.

2. If "George Noyce has a delusion and Dr. Rachel does not exist", it means that neither George nor Ted have ever left Shutter Island, and the conversation between Ted and Dr. Rachel is purely his personal fantasy, and Shutter Island is just a normal mental hospital, but most of the patients are high-risk patients.

3. If "George Noyce has no illusions and Dr. Rachel is really human", it means that both George and Ted did not belong to Shutter Island. And Dr. Rachel's statement is true, Shutter Island does engage in inhumane human experimentation.

4. If "George Noyce has no illusions and Dr. Rachel does not exist", it means that both George and Ted did not belong to Shutter Island. Moreover, even though Dr. Rachel is purely Ted's personal fantasy, and since George is not delusional, Shutter Island does engage in some inhumane human experimentation.

Rachel, the female prisoner who killed her own flesh and blood, mysteriously escaped from the hospital and hid on an isolated island. Teddy suspects that the attending physician, John Cowley, is trying to hide the inside story, and reveals that his true purpose is to find the administrator who burned his wife, Delores, to death. At the same time, he also wants to investigate the use of mentally ill prisoners in the United States to conduct human science experiments.

Synopsis:

The story takes place in 1954, when federal law enforcement officer Ted Daniel (Leonardo DiCaprio) and his newly sent partner Chuck (Mark Ruffalo) are ordered to go to the island to investigate the matter, and the doctor in charge, Cowley, receives them and is in charge of assisting in the investigation.

And Ted came here for another hidden purpose: to find ** Ladis, who let his wife die in the fire. Over the course of the investigation, more and more evidence supported Ted's inference:

In addition to the 66 psychiatric offenders with files, there is also a person with the number 67, but neither the prison guards, nor the doctors, nor other patients have flatly denied this.

I will give you a humble opinion below.

1.The protagonist is a madman, and the doctors want to use the **method) of role-playing to ** his mental illness, so he is not locked up in the lighthouse, and with the cooperation of the doctors, he is the protagonist in his fantasy world.

2.I don't know why he always smokes cigarettes, as for what he can imagine in such detail, **The doctor behind him also mentioned that he was thoughtful when introducing his condition, and the names he imagined were actually obtained by his name through different spelling methods, which can also show that this person's thinking ability is really good.

As for whether there will be a sequel, you can die for this, no matter how it is, it is impossible to come out with a sequel to say what happens to the protagonist after he recovers from his illness; As for the final dialogue, it is indeed very connotative, to live like a monster or to die as a good person, that is, the protagonist is very self-blaming for killing his wife after learning the truth, and he does not want to live with this burden, so he chooses to undergo surgery, deliberately making 'Chuck' think that he has not woken up yet, so that he can have surgery. Being able to say this sentence shows that the protagonist is actually awake in the end.

ps: Did the landlord notice, and when the protagonist talked to his assistant in the end, the focus of the camera was on 'Chuck', why did he aim at him, so I don't need to say much about this.

Shutter Island is a classic. I just watched it again. When you asked, I still want to watch it again...

Listen to me slowly, I forgot what the name of the main actor is, let's call him Jack, Jack is a World War II veteran, his wife forgot to see the two children because of something, the child drowned, he came back and killed his wife by mistake, and then he repented and hallucinated, and he believed that he really entered the world he hallucinated. Then he was sent to Shutter Island, which was the beginning, he woke up on the ship, he called his attending doctor Chuck, did he notice that as soon as he entered the door, all the guards were on alert, for a World War II veteran, suffering from severe mental illness, could get out of control at any time, and then he began his investigation, to find out who was the 76th person, what kind of meeting to have, in fact, everyone knew that it was him who was sick, so he didn't cooperate so actively, and then he asked one by one, Did you notice that all the people he asked were afraid of him, and then you might understand, a series of investigations he did on the island, and on the way to the lighthouse, Chuck told him that you got the list and see who it was, why did you look for ,......?Chuck is missing ......The bald dean in the lighthouse said that in order to introduce a new ** method for the patient**, the doctor enters the patient's fantasy world, so as to understand him, distort the world he thinks, and if this ** method does not work, he will have to perform surgery to remove the patient's brain lobe. In the lighthouse, Jack finally recognized the reality, and when he woke up, Jack found that the world was so quiet, as if the truth had been revealed, and everything in the past was a dream.

When Chuck thought he was well, Jack called him Chuck and said that even if he knew what the truth was, he couldn't live in the world he thought he was, so what was the point, and then followed the medical staff into the lighthouse for a white lobe removal operation. This is the most touching part of this movie.

He was also the first to go out from here.