If the parents have given all the family property to the elder brother, what should the elder brothe

Updated on society 2024-07-31
39 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-15

    It can be passedLegal meansIf you solve it, you can go to your brother to communicate and ask for the family property back. Honoring our parents has always been usChinese nationThe traditional virtues, we should everyone do this, because parents give us life, provide us with an environment to live in, accompany us to grow up, and always give us the best things, it can be said that most parents have given their children their youth, lest their children live a bad life, when they are sick, always stay by their side, when they succeed, silently bless them behind their backs, this is our parents, do not ask for anything in return, just blindly give.

    First, it can be resolved by legal means.

    When the children take the family property and do not fulfill the obligation to support the elderly, they have violated the law and should be morally condemned, the elder brother of the family, as the elder brother, should fulfill his responsibilities and set a good example for other brothers and sisters, they do not honor their parents, they should protect the legitimate rights and interests of their parents through legal means.

    Second, you can go to your brother to communicate.

    When the elder brother is unwilling to fulfill the responsibility of supporting his parents, we can communicate with the elder brother, for a while can not understand the hardships of the parents, can not understand the feelings of the parents for themselves, if we can change the elder brother's view through communication, this is also okay, so that the elder brother can have a better view of his parents, so that his parents can change their own views, and achieve a better self.

    3. Get your family property back.

    If after communicating with my brother, my brother still does not change his opinion, then we have to be tougher, otherwise it will only make my brother more excessive, we can get the family property back through legal means, so that parents can live a better life, so that they can live happily in the rest of their lives, or solve it through the law, our country will definitely safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of parents.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-14

    Your brother should be taken to court, after all, your brother has taken all the family property, and your brother must have the obligation to support his parents.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    He can be sued because it is the duty of the child to support his parents, and he can sue him if he fails to do so.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    If the parents have given all the family property to the elder brother, there is a right and an obligation, and the elder brother should file a lawsuit with the court to demand that the elder brother fulfill the obligation to support his parents.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    It can be resolved by legal means. Holding the family property but not supporting the elderly should also be morally condemned.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    If this is not tight, the elder brother evades the maintenance obligation, and the court can sue and ruling.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Hello, I hope it can help you with the following for your problem!

    Based on your question, I would like to judge that both brothers are adults.

    First of all, we need to judge the situation according to the problem you have explained

    Whether the elder brother is a person with no or limited capacity for civil conduct.

    A person with no or limited capacity for civil conduct refers to an elder brother who is unable or unable to fully recognize his own conduct. )

    If the elder brother is a person with no or limited capacity for civil conduct, in accordance with the provisions of Article 28 of the Civil Code, an adult with no or limited capacity for civil conduct shall be the guardian of the following persons with guardianship capacity in order: (1) Spouse; (2) Parents and children; (3) Other close relatives; (4) Other individuals or organizations willing to serve as guardians, but with the consent of the residents' committee, villagers' committee, or civil affairs department for the ward's domicile. It can be seen from this that the younger brother does belong to other close relatives and has the obligation to support the elder brother when the elder brother has no spouse, parents, or children.

    However, if there are other people who voluntarily support their elder brother with the consent of the relevant organization, in accordance with the provisions of Article 30 of the Civil Code, the persons who have guardianship qualifications in accordance with the law may agree to determine the guardian. The agreement determines that the guardian shall respect the true wishes of the ward. With the consent of the elder brother, another person or organization may voluntarily assume the obligation of support.

    If the elder brother is not a person who has no civil capacity or limited civil capacity, the younger brother or sister who has been raised by the elder brother or sister in accordance with Article 1075 of the Civil Code and has the ability to afford it has the obligation to support the elder brother or sister who lacks the ability to work and lacks the ability to live. Therefore, if the following conditions are met, the younger brother has the obligation to support the elder brother.

    1) The younger brother was raised by the elder brother;

    2) The younger brother has the ability to support him;

    3) The elder brother lacks the ability to work and lacks income**.

    It is only a personal opinion, only used as a personal suggestion, and does not bear any legal risks.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Generally speaking, a younger sibling has no obligation to support an elderly sibling, and the obligation to support only arises in certain circumstances.

    Article 29 of the Marriage Act: "An older brother or sister who can afford it shall have the obligation to support a minor brother or sister whose parents have died or whose parents are unable to support them. Younger brothers and sisters who are raised by older brothers and sisters who can afford it have the obligation to support older brothers and sisters who lack the ability to work and lack livelihood.

    Accordingly, there are conditions for younger siblings to bear the obligation to support their older siblings, including: first, the younger brother and sister are raised by the elder brother or sister; Second, the younger brother and sister have the ability to afford it, that is, they have the ability to fulfill the obligation to support them.

    Third, the brother and sister lack the ability to work and lack of life. In this case, Yu Xiaolin was raised by you, supported by you to study and become a talent, and has a certain financial affordability, so he should financially support and support you who have lost his ability to work and live.

    Extended Materials. What it takes for younger siblings to raise older siblings.

    1. Brothers and sisters must lack the ability to work and lack of life.

    2. The elder brother or sister does not have the first-order support obligor or the first-order support obligor does not have the ability to support. That is, the older sibling has no spouse or children, or has but is dead or unable to support them.

    3. The younger siblings were raised by the older siblings, and the younger siblings can afford it. The above must be present at the same time in order for an obligation relationship to arise.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Legally, the younger brother is not obliged to support the elder brother. But if the parents. died early.

    The younger brother was brought up by the elder brother. The two brothers are more age-apart. Then when my brother gets old.

    The younger brother should also support him. It makes sense that my brother should do the same.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The law stipulates that the younger brother has no obligation to support the elder brother, brotherhood, flesh and blood, broken femur and tendons, and brothers have the obligation to help each other, so it all depends on how they do it, and good luck will come naturally if they do more good deeds. Wangcaine.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Legally, the younger brother is not obliged to support the elder brother. There is only the obligation to support parents and children. But China is a moral society.

    I remember seeing a report on the Internet, a couple had their first child when they were older, working outside, they gave birth to a second child at home, and they were in good health at the beginning and could raise them by themselves, but who knew that when the second child was 5-6 years old, he was weak and sick, and he had no ability to raise him, so they asked the boss to help raise him, but the boss was unwilling, so they sued the boss, and the boss was sentenced to pay child support. If the younger brother wants to help support the elder brother in the case of strong economic ability, if the elder brother is lazy to do it, the younger brother can not raise it, and if the elder brother is sick or disabled, the younger brother should be supported, after all, it is a brother. This is just a personal opinion.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The younger brother in law is not obligated to support the elder brother. The two sides are brothers, not father and son. There is no legal obligation on the part of the parties for maintenance. The younger brother has the ability to help the elder brother.

  13. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    There is an order of maintenance in law. If a parent passes away. The elder brother has no children and a spouse. The younger brother has the obligation to support the elder brother. At the same time, he also has the right to inherit his brother's estate.

  14. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    No, but there is no child support, and the immediate family members have the task of supporting them ethically and are not legally obliged.

  15. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    In general, you don't have the obligation to support yourself in this situation, but you can help take care of it when you don't have other relatives. After all, they are siblings

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    There is no obligation to support his brother. The law stipulates that the younger brother has no obligation to support the elder brother, and the brothers have the obligation to help each other, but they do not leave all the work to the other party.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    In law, the younger brother has the right to say that he is obliged to support his elder brother, except that there is no one in the family, and if the elder brother is disabled or has any problems, then the younger brother has money, to support the elder brother, if he is a sound person, otherwise why should the younger brother give him a goat?

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    In law, the younger brother has no obligation to support the elder brother, and the younger brother only has the obligation to support his parents, and has no obligation to support his siblings of the same kind.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    When an older brother has no spouse, no children, and no parents, you are the closest person to him, and you have an obligation.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    If it is two brothers, the parents are gone, and the younger brother is the closest person. He doesn't care who cares, no.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Is the younger brother legally obligated to support the elder brother? I think that in such a case, there should be an obligation to support it.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Legally, they have this mutual obligation to take care of each other. There is a legal relationship.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Legally, the younger brother has no obligation to support the elder brother, but he will do his best to help the elder brother affectionately.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    If the elder brother is living a difficult life or is disabled, he will be legally obliged by the younger brother to support him.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Legally, the younger brother is not obliged to support the elder brother.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Legal Analysis: In principle, no. It is only in certain circumstances that an obligation of maintenance may arise between siblings.

    Legal basis: Article 1074 of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China Grandparents who can afford it have the obligation to support their minor grandchildren whose parents have died or whose parents are unable to support them. Grandchildren who can afford it have the obligation to support their grandparents who have died or whose children are unable to support them.

    Article 23 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of the Rights and Interests of the Elderly: The elderly and their spouses have the obligation to support each other. Where a younger brother or sister who is supported by an older brother or sister becomes an adult and has the ability to afford it, he or she has an obligation to support the elder brother or sister who is old and has no support.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Hello! Children have the obligation to support the elderly, and legally speaking, the elder brother is not obliged to support the younger brother, unless the parents die early and the younger brother is a minor.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Generally speaking, the elder brother is not obliged to take care of the younger brother, but if the parents are old and incapacitated or pass away, the elder brother should morally support the younger brother, after all, blood is thicker than water.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    The law in our country stipulates that if the parents are not able to raise the child, then his brother or sister is obliged to raise the younger brother, so the elder brother is obliged to support the younger brother.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    If the younger brother has no other supporter, morally speaking, the elder brother should give the younger brother support and help, blood is thicker than water.

    Good deeds are rewarded, and God will favor the kind.

    Glass king Cao Dewang, when he was a child, suffered a lot, worked hard and finally became the king of glass, he is very kind, honest and trustworthy, he donated a total of 11 billion to poor orphans and schools, etc., helping many people, so people.

    As long as the virtue is high and kindness is very respectable.

    Andy Lau often does public welfare and is kind.

    As early as 1991, when the East China flood, he donated 5 million yuan for charity, and later Andy Lau also silently made a lot of charity every year.

    Huang Xiaoming, often doing public welfare, when Wenchuan was the first to do, Huang Xiaoming donated 100,000 yuan for the first time and took the lead in donating blood, and then donated millions of materials one after another, and also donated one million to pledge a pair of pandas.

    So good is rewarded.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    There is no legal obligation of support between siblings. 1. If the elder brother or sister who can afford it dies or the parents are unable to support them, the minor younger siblings have the obligation to support them. 2. The younger brothers and sisters who are raised by their brothers and sisters who can afford it have the obligation to support the brothers and sisters who have lost their ability to work or lack economic support.

  32. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    If the younger brother has no other supporter, the elder brother is obliged to support the younger brother.

  33. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    The elder brother is not obligated to support the younger brother, but if the younger brother is left alone, you must take care of it. Because you are the elder brother of your brother, you are your brother's caretaker without your parents.

  34. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Divide the situation. For example, if the younger brother is a minor, and the guardian is the elder brother, then the elder brother has to fulfill the obligation to support him. If both parents are complete, or if the younger brother is an adult, the elder brother has no obligation to support him.

  35. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    The elder brother must have the obligation to support the younger brother, which is what everyone should do.

  36. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    The elder brother has no legal obligation to support the younger brother. It's just that brotherly love makes him take care of his younger brother.

  37. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Is your brother an adult? Do you have a physical disability? Mentally problematic?

    Is there personal freedom? If you don't, then you don't have to. Of course, you are related by blood, and if he is really in trouble, if you have the ability, you can help him without affecting the family relationship.

    But help is not to help relatives, and emergency is not to help the poor.

  38. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    If the parents are dead or unable to support them, then the elder brother or sister has the obligation to support the minor brother or sister.

  39. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    The elder brother or sister who can afford it has the obligation to support the minor brother or sister whose parents have died, or whose parents are unable to support them.

Related questions
32 answers2024-07-31

What you said is indeed a problem, but now some parents are more open-minded, they don't give all the family property to their sons, they just say that their daughters are going to get married, maybe he won't give you the house and land, but in terms of money, it's still a lot. Your daughter and son are the same, giving, so when they are old and sick, the money and effort may be needed by both the daughter and the son, but even when they are old, it is generally the son who presides over this matter.

20 answers2024-07-31

In fact, most of the elderly in rural areas will not ask for that. Even if the son is really difficult, he will only ask his daughter to help, and will not "force the head of the cow without drinking water". Individual phenomena do exist, but there are few who insist on paying regardless of their daughter's life or death. >>>More

24 answers2024-07-31

The old man gave all the family property to his granddaughter, does the son have the right not to provide for the elderly? The son has no right not to support the elderly, because the old man raised you when he was a child, in the law of the country, the old man is old, you should be filial to the old man, Lao Tzu life This is also a kind of national regulation.

33 answers2024-07-31

Acceptable. Because there are many such things around him, he can't change anything by himself, the old man only gave the family property to his son, and the others treated his daughter very well, and he didn't say that he was patriarchal, she just gave the family property to his son, a big reason was influenced by traditional thinking. >>>More

19 answers2024-07-31

Patriarchy is very common in some families, in our place, some families are not allowed to read after the girl finishes junior high school at most, and the daughter who marries out spills the water, maybe your parents are this mentality! Now give everything good to your brother! Thinking about letting your younger brother provide for them in the future, in fact, I don't think these are anything, you said it yourself, you don't care about these materials, maybe what you care about is feeling uncomfortable! >>>More