The new Water Margin is good looking or the old version is good looking

I think the old version is good! It's more in line with the original! The actors played very well! Picture scenes, war scenes, martial arts scenes.

It's all real, and it makes people look like they are from the Song Dynasty! New edition.

The technical special effects are good! The picture scene is very clear! The shooting is very complete, 108 good sweats have appeared, if you want to pursue the truth, want to understand the hearts of the characters, and want to understand the dark society reflected in the Water Margin, go and watch it.

The old version! If only you are looking for visual enjoyment! With the mindset of entertainment, that looks.

The new version is good! To each his own good! The choice is yours!!

Several of the main characters in the new version are not as good as the old version, such as Li Kui.

Wu Song et al. However, the new version has a lot of outstanding features, that is, the 108 stars of the Water Margin have all shown their faces, and most of them have some scenes, and many characters have added enough scenes before Liangshan, but they ended in a hurry to conquer Fang La. In addition, Lin Chong's melancholy, Yang Zhi's contradictions, as well as Ximen Qing, Shi Jin, Chai Jin, Shi Xiu, Zhang Qing These little handsome guys, Pan Jinlian, Yan Poxi and other beauties are all highlights.

It's worth a look.

Share it with your friends :

The old version is more faithful to the original, and the new version is more prominent in the personality of the characters, and the style is also lively.

I think the new version is good-looking, the actors are handsome, the women are beautiful, the movements are good-looking, and they are super good, which is worth watching.

Turnips and cabbages have their own love. The new version of the Water Margin, I've also seen it, and I feel okay.

The old version, I don't think the new Water Margin looks as good as the Water Margin for a long time.

Zhang Hanyu is good-looking.

Good looking and being in line with the original are two concepts. Good looks are subjective experiences that vary from person to person. Personally, I like Zhang Hanyu's version, which shows Song Jiang heroically.

And there are more episodes, which means more content, basically 108 will have frontal shots. Li Xuejian's version may be more in line with the real Song Jiang, but the number of episodes is relatively small, and there are many deleted things. However, the background of Li Xuejian's version is good, and every time there is an important fight, that suona is very feeling.

And the martial arts instructor is Yuan Heping.

In line with the original work, it is an objective evaluation, both versions have been adapted, Li Xuejian's version of Pan Jinlian's portrayal, Lin Chong died before Fang La, Li Kui and Pang Wanchun's sister were ambiguous, and they were all relatively large secondary creations. Zhang Hanyu's version has also changed a lot, and what impresses me is that Luda and Jin Cuilian have different feelings. and when Chao Gai died, he discussed the issue of Zhao'an with Song Jiang, which is also very different from the original work.

As for the various tragic deaths of the Zhengfangla brothers, there are many changes in both versions. Overall, it looks good or Zhang Hanyu's version, if you want to conform to the original work, then you still have to look at the original work. To put it another way, there are many versions of the so-called original work, such as the traditional version and the simplified version.

Some of the poems are different in different versions. But just look at the 120 editions of the People's Literature Publishing House.

As the two best films in the Water Margin series, the CCTV version of Water Margin and the new version of Water Margin have always been compared by everyone. Yesterday, a friend asked, many people said that the CCTV version of the Water Margin is a classic, far beyond the new version of the Water Margin, why in his opinion, the new version of the Water Margin is better, so that he has the patience to watch it, and the CCTV version of the Water Margin The whole rhythm feels wrong, in his opinion, it is undoubtedly the new version of the Water Margin that is better filmed.

The old version of "Water Margin" is good-looking, that is because the actors are all pure and natural China's four classical masterpieces, and now they have been adapted into TV series and put on the silver screen, which has been recognized by many audiences. The old version of the TV series was filmed for a long time, so the clarity of the work was very blurred, and the handling of the stunts was too rough, so in order to meet the aesthetics of today's people, they were all remade. Although the old version of the work has many flaws, but the flaws are not hidden, the old version of the work has restored the original work as much as possible in terms of plot processing and costume modeling, even in the details of the shooting environment and framing, the director has put a lot of effort into it, so it is regarded as a classic by the audience, and there is a reason.

The old version looks good. Many of the characters in it have become classics of "Water Margin", such as Song Jiang played by Li Xuejian, as well as Lin Chong, Wu Song, etc., such characters have distinct personalities, flesh and blood, which have long been engraved in the hearts of the audience and can no longer be erased.

Isn't Water Margin a masterpiece, since it is a masterpiece, it must refer to the old version that it is good-looking, and it is definitely not Zhang Hanyu's version, because Zhang Hanyu is a later version.

Water Margin, Journey to the West, and Dream of Red Mansions are all masterpieces, "Masterpieces" refers to classic works, and also refers to the first shooting work, and the first part refers to the earliest and oldest version.

The new version looks a little better. Because the new version of Water Margin has enough length, many details are filmed very well, making the story more full, especially in the scenes of Lin Chonghuo and Wang Lun, which is more in line with the aesthetics of modern people.

The only downside of the 98 version is that it compresses a lot of the plot, but the classic chapters are all there, and you will feel like you have a camera recorded directly in ancient times.

At present, one is the version starring Li Xuejian and the version starring Zhang Hanyu.

Although the former invited the famous Hong Kong martial arts instructor Yuan Heping, the martial arts picture still has many loopholes. What's even worse is to break superstition and make a heroic legend into a historical drama, especially the image of the protagonist Song Jiang is extremely obscene, I can't help but say that the starring Li Xuejian is very skilled, but if the direction is wrong, the whole character will be ruined.

And Zhang Hanyu's version of "Water Margin" Song Jiang's image is closer to a hero, and this should be the color that Song Jiang should have, the story does not avoid the so-called heaven and earth, and the storytelling is much freer. However, some changes are hard injuries, such as making Lu Zhishen and the rescued Jin Cuilian have feelings, which is also ridiculous.

Overall, the latter is more like a heroic legend, and the filming methods are stronger than the former, and they are generally better.