If Liu Bei led Zhuge Liang to attack Wu, would there be a different result?

Updated on history 2024-03-25
18 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    As we all know, during the Three Kingdoms period, the three kingdoms of Wei, Shu and Wu fought for each other, and no one refused to bow down. At first, this situation continued. However, after Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou and was killed in a fiasco, the general trend of the world began to change.

    Later, Liu Bei led his army to crusade against Wu, but unfortunately he was defeated in the end. So, if Liu Bei takes Zhuge Liang to fight Wu, will he still lose? Lu Xun's answer was concise and clear.

    At the beginning, in order to be able to better fight against the powerful Cao Cao, Liu Bei chose to join forces with Sun Quan. After forming an alliance, they did succeed in containing Cao Cao's forces and won a resounding victory in the Battle of Red Cliffs. Cao Cao was defeated and returned, which can be described as a loss of troops and embarrassment.

    However, later, in order to capture Jingzhou, Sun Quan actually sent troops to attack Guan Yu. For various reasons, Guan Yu lost Jingzhou, not to mention, and even lost his life. You must know that Guan Yu is Liu Bei's sworn brother, and they have lived and died together for many years, and how many times they have fought side by side.

    Seeing the tragic death of his brother, Liu Bei naturally couldn't tolerate it.

    So he resolutely led the army to conquer Wu in person, so as to avenge Guan Yu. As a clever military advisor beside Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang knew that the odds of winning were not good, and he didn't approve of Liu Bei's doing, but Liu Bei was furious at this time, and he would listen to it. Subsequently, Liu Bei launched a large-scale battle of Yiling.

    Speaking of which, this is actually a false war that should not be waged. Because the power of Shu was the weakest among the three kingdoms at that time, after this battle, it directly led to the complete decline of Shu from then on.

    If Liu Bei could calm down, maybe the back of Shu would not decline and perish so quickly. At that time, Liu Bei did not take Zhuge Liang with him, so it was even more difficult to defeat Wu Guo. Sure enough, when Liu Bei's army arrived in the Yiling area, it was firmly blocked by Lu Xun.

    At this time, the Shu army had penetrated deep into the hinterland of Wu, and the battle line was too long, which was simply a crisis. In addition, the Shu army had to fight against the enemy on the one hand, and on the other hand, it had to take care of the supplies in the rear, which seemed to be inadequate.

    In addition, Liu Bei himself is a brave and unscrupulous person, and he can't think of any clever ways to break through the enemy's iron wall. Lu Xun took the opportunity to use a plan, that is, to burn the company camp, which caught Liu Bei's army by surprise and was quickly defeated. After that, Liu Bei had to flee with the army, and Lu Xun took advantage of the victory to pursue, and the momentum was like a bamboo.

    Behind, because the soldiers around Liu Bei fought desperately, they were not immediately wiped out by the enemy. Eventually, Liu Bei fled to the White Emperor City and soon fell ill and died. If Liu Bei had taken Zhuge Liang to attack Wu, would he still lose?

    Zhuge Liang is skillful in strategy, if he is by Liu Bei's side, Shu should not lose. And Lu Xun also said that my plan could not be concealed from Zhuge Liang, but fortunately this person was not there, so I made a great success.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    At least it won't end up in a big defeat, and Liu Bei is likely not to be angry to death, Shu will not lose its backbone, and it will not be buried in Liu Chan's hands, and the country of Shu may still maintain its ten years.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Not necessarily, Zhuge Liang is cautious in his use of soldiers, and he will never approve of the whole army camping in the camp, but it is difficult to say whether Liu Bei can listen to it, Liu Bei is confident that the soldiers are strong and strong at this time, his heart is swollen, and he is conceited, so he may not listen.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    There will be different results. Although Zhuge Liang accompanied Liu Bei may not defeat Eastern Wu, he will definitely not be defeated by Yiling.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because of the incident of cutting down Wu, Zhuge Liang did not approve of it, and his political views were different.

    Secondly, under the influence of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, everyone thinks that Zhuge Liang is clever, but in fact, Zhuge is an out-and-out politician, and his military talent is not outstanding. Liu Bei's most important advisor was Fa Zheng.

    Also, at that time, Liu Bei's foundation in Shuzhong was not stable, and someone needed to preside over the overall situation.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Governing Sichuan is his lifeblood.

    If you go with Liu Bei, what if Wei comes to attack.

    He is trusted by Prime Minister Liu Bei.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    According to historical facts, this is normal, because at that time, Liu Bei's mastermind was Fa Zheng, and Zhuge Liang was mainly responsible for logistics support; According to what the romance says, because Zhuge didn't agree to rashly send troops to attack Wu, and Liu Bei insisted on going, so it was the awkward mentality of "I can do it without you".

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    **At that time, it was said that Zhuge Liang stayed in Chengdu, and then Liu Bei took Feng Xiao to conquer Wu State, This is for the stability of the rear, which can be seen from leaving Guan Yu behind.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Xishu has just been pacified, and there are still many opposition forces and Liu Zhang's diehard forces in the country, so a strong person must suppress it.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    In fact, Zhuge Liang did not agree with Liu Bei's attack on Wu. Therefore, Liu Bei, who was furious, decided to keep him. This also means to let Zhuge Liang see his own ability. It can be seen that Liu Bei was already a little complacent at that time.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Zhuge Liang is the prime minister, and at the beginning of the founding of the People's Republic of China, he was very busy. Besides, in fact, Zhuge Liang is not as famous as Liu Bei in military affairs, and when he came out of Qishan, Wei didn't know what Zhuge Liang was doing.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    If Zhuge Liang went with him, then Yizhou would have no one to guard.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Does he want Cao Wei to take him to the nest? Since ancient times, the emperor has personally conquered, and the prime minister has stabilized.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    The capital of that country was unguarded, and Cao Wei took the opportunity to go south.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Why did Liu Bei lose to Lu Xun, but he was burned by Lu Xun.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    is because Zhuge Liang is the target of everyone, he only needs to bring Zhuge Liang's tricks, and he doesn't need to bring others to the battlefield, otherwise there will be a possibility of death.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Liu Bei knew that Zhuge Liang was already injured at that time, and he couldn't bear to let Zhuge Liang follow him back and forth, hoping that Zhuge Liang would recover well.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    At that time, it was necessary to let Zhuge Liang stabilize the rear, so that he could be prepared.

Related questions
28 answers2024-03-25

will defeat Soochow Lu Xun. At that time, Liu Bei thought that he was very strategic and could win. Zhuge Liang was in charge of production and supplies at that time.

18 answers2024-03-25

Zhuge Liang has the world in his heart, worries about the country and the people, and it is impossible to take refuge in a traitor like Cao Cao If Zhuge Liang takes refuge in Cao Cao, Cao Cao will avoid and envy Zhuge Liang's intelligence and ruin a great man I also believe that Cao Cao will shine and unify China soon! Because Liu Bei claimed to be a fish, and without the water of Zhuge Liang, Liu Bei would not be able to become a member of the Three Kingdoms. Even Cao Cao's great deeds will not fall into the hands of Sima.

21 answers2024-03-25

There is no such thing as the Three Kingdoms.

15 answers2024-03-25

This is also a very big regret left by Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition. >>>More

18 answers2024-03-25

If Zhuge Liang did not go on a northern expedition, but recuperated, what would be the ultimate fate of Shu? Zhuge Liang was the prime minister of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period, when Liu Bei condescended to Liu Biao's subordinates and only occupied a small place like Xinye. After Liu Bei got Zhuge Liang, he first took part of Jingzhou, and then took Liu Zhang's Yizhou, and then attacked Hanzhong in one go. >>>More